When I got pregnant, my only close friend who had already been through pregnancy and birth was Elisa. She gave me a trove of books, including "What to Expect When You're Expecting," which has been the ubiquitous pregnancy book for more than two decades.
With almost 15 million copies in print, I figured this would be my go-to guide. But soon after cracking it open, I decided I hated the book. I found it alarmist and tone-deaf; far from reassuring me, it made me worry about ridiculous things. And their dietary recommendations? Are you freaking kidding me?
This article explored the book's genesis and evolution, including some of the complaints:
Despite the huge success, mothers like to debate the book's advice on message boards, and mock titles have emerged such as "What to Freak Out About When You're Expecting." On urbanbaby.com one can still find references to the book's warnings, toned down in later editions, that common fetal hiccups could signal a severe umbilical cord problem and that oral sex on a woman could in rare cases cause a fatal embolism.
Turns out author Heidi Murkoff has heeded the criticism and revamped the book, inside and out. Check the new cover: gone is the mousy woman in the rocking chair. She's been replaced by a hip mama decked out in designer jeans, high-heeled boots and a form-fitting blouse:
This new edition, largely rewritten, is a chance to present a version that's "more reassuring, more positive, more empathetic than ever," its author says.
But the revamping raises a larger question: Can this iconic tome ever be as relevant as it once was? Can any book? When "What to Expect" was launched in 1984, it was the only thing of its kind out there — a guide written not by doctors but by women, for women.
Now there are lots of others. But there's also the big wide Web world out there, and it's not just all those sites offering medical information. This is the age of the message board, where a woman who has a strange ache or pain at 3 a.m. can fire off a cyber-question: "Late-night cramps at 5 months pg, dh asleep, what do i do?" Answers come within moments.
"It's this whole new community," says Susan Kane, editor in chief of Parenting magazine. "Women are starting to trust one another and not listen to the experts so much."
Murkoff has adjusted to this new reality as well, launching WhatToExpect.com three years ago. Apparently it's wildly popular, with 1.7 million page views per month, second only to BabyCenter.
What do you all think? Did you love or hate "What to Expect"? Would you give the revised version a second chance? Do you appreciate the hip new cover mom? And would you still turn to old-fashioned pregnancy books in this age of instant feedback on the Internet?