Small Schools Rule
by Elisa
Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 05:52:36 AM PDT
Newsweek recently compiled a list of the country's top high schools and came to a not so small conclusion: Small schools rule. Not only are they sprouting everywhere due to funding by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, but they made up a disproportionate number of the top five percent of Newsweek's rankings.
Even respectable large urban and suburban schools -- take Hillsdale High School in San Mateo, Calif., for example -- are breaking up into "houses" to give students individualized attention and deliver higher graduation rates.
So in 2003 Hillsdale remade itself into three "houses," romantically designated Florence, Marrakech and Kyoto. Each of the 300 arriving ninth graders are randomly assigned to one of the houses, where they will keep the same four core subject teachers for two years, before moving on to another for 11th and 12th grades. The closeness this system fosters was reinforced by the institution of "advisory" classes. Teachers meet with students in groups of 25, five mornings a week, for open-ended discussions of everything from homework problems to bullying and bad Saturday-night dates. The advisers also meet with students privately and stay in touch with parents, so they are deeply invested in the students' success. "We're constantly talking about one another's advisees, " says English teacher Chris Crockett. "If you hear that yours isn't doing well in algebra, or see them sitting outside the dean's office, it's like a personal failure." Along with the new structure came a more rigorous academic program; the percentage of freshmen taking biology jumped from 17 to 95. "It was rough for some, but by senior year, two thirds have moved up to physics," says Gilbert. "Our kids are coming to school in part because they know there are adults here who know them and care for them." But not all schools show advances after downsizing, and it remains to be seen whether smaller schools will be a panacea.
Newsweek developed its list by counting the number of college-level exams students take in May -- Cambridge, International Baccalaureate and Advanced Placement -- and dividing that number by the number of graduating seniors. Any school with a ratio of 1.000 or higher made the list.
What do you think, MotherTalkers? Do you think school size matters in student achievement?

In case you missed it, Newsweek ran a cover story on 