Mother Talkers

Peace and Preschool

Tue Jun 05, 2007 at 11:21:19 PM PDT

Every weekday morning, I drop my son off at preschool. As I continue on my way to work, I turn on the radio and hear about the latest horrors taking place a hemisphere away. While there is a great gulf between the violence in Iraq and my daily routine, there are also threads that tie them together. Two of the most influential preschool educational methods--Montessori and Reggio Emilia--were the by-products of war.

When Dr. Maria Montessori refused to turn the children in her schools into soldiers, Mussolini forced her into exile. Later, she fled Spain when the Spanish Civil War broke out. By 1949, Montessori had lived through two World Wars, and the pursuit of peace became the primary goal of her education model.

In 1932, Montessori addressed the International Bureau of Education in Geneva:

If a person were to grow up with a healthy soul, enjoying the full development of a strong character and a clear intellect, they could not endure to uphold two kinds of justice—the one protecting life and the other destroying it. Nor would they consent to cultivate in their heart both love and hate. Neither could they tolerate two disciplines—the one aimed at building, and the other at tearing down what has been built.

Better humans than we are would use their intellects and the attainments of civilization to end the fury of war. War would not be a problem for them at all. They would see it simply as a barbarous state, opposed to civilization—an absurd and incomprehensible phenomenon, as expendable and defeatable as the plague.

In 1931, Mahatma Ghandi and Maria Montessori met at the Montessori Training College in London. Gandhi personally taught all the children in his Ashrams using techniques similar to and inspired by the Montessori system.

I first observed a Montessori classroom in the early 90s, when my then-boyfriend's son began a Montessori preschool. My main impression was surprise that there were so many children packed in a room, each doing his or her own thing, yet chaos did not reign. Invisible rules seemed to guide the movements of the little comets. There were personal space delineations, and rituals to invite, accept, and decline play with others. Although I knew nothing of Montessori's ideas, I remember thinking that whatever was going on in the classroom would be beneficial to future denizens of a population-dense world. An intense amount of diverse independent activity was occuring harmoniously in close quarters. Maybe Maria was on to something...

  • ::

"We cannot achieve world harmony simply by attempting to unite all these adult people who are so different,"  said Maria Montessori, "but we can achieve it as we begin with the child who is not born with racial prejudices."

Many of Montessori's precepts were designed to cultivate peace-makers: mixed-age groups compelled older kids to mentor younger ones, students took responsibility for the care of the classroom, and community service was required.

The teacher in my son's preschool class follows the Reggio Emilia Approach, which was started by the parents of the villages around Reggio Emilia in Italy after World War II.

Ironically, this lively method of learning literally arose from the rubble of World War II. Sick of war, the citizens of the town of Reggio Emilia in northern Italy used the money from the sale of old tanks to invest in their future by building quality preschools. A young educator named Loris Malaguzzi was impressed by the community's commitment to its children and worked with the people to develop this child-honoring approach.

In this approach, teachers observe the children closely, noting what attracts their interest. They then improvise involved, long-term projects that draw the children in deeper. The kids come together and strategize; they work toward the next step of the project. From le wiki:

Regardless of their origins, successful projects are those that generate a sufficient amount of interest and uncertainty to provoke children's creative thinking and problem-solving and are open to different avenues of exploration. Because curriculum decisions are based on developmental and sociocultural concerns, small groups of children of varying abilities and interests, including those with special needs, work together on projects.

Projects begin with teachers observing and questioning children about the topic of interest. Based on children's responses, teachers introduce materials, questions, and opportunities that provoke children to further explore the topic. While some of these teacher provocations are anticipated, projects often move in unanticipated directions as a result of problems children identify. Thus, curriculum planning and implementation revolve around open-ended and often long-term projects that are based on the reciprocal nature of teacher-directed and child-initiated activity.

The people of Reggio Emilia believed that the best way to rebuild their war-torn town was to come together around the education of their youngest citizens. The education system they developed was based on maximum participation by the community; steering meetings were held in the evenings so all the working mothers and fathers could participate. Perhaps as a result of their wartime experience, these Italian citizens wanted to teach their children how to come together as one, to pursue interests and goals with spontenaiety and flexibility, and to draw upon their collective problem-solving abilities to maneuver around obstacles. This may not prevent war, as was Maria Montessori's hope, but it may give children the skills and fortitude to survive it.

Tags: preschool, war, peace, montessori, reggio emilia (all tags)

View Comments | 28 comments