Mother Talkers

How involved do we really want fathers to be?

Fri Mar 16, 2007 at 04:59:28 AM PDT

When I got pregnant and enrolled in our insurance company's well baby program, we received two free books: What to Expect and The Expectant Father.  The Expectant Father was a nice touch, a way to say to the expectant dads, you're involved in this too buddy!

As far as pregnancy goes, the father's role is obviously one of support.  "We" are not pregnant.

After the baby is here, with the exception of nursing, all aspects of childrearing including decision-making can be shared equally.  However, this is often not the case and the authors of The Expectant Father bemoan this current state of affairs.  Some of this is society's fault according to the authors:

Quite simply, Americans don't value fatherhood as much as motherhood.  Even the words conjure up different images: motherhood is equated with caring, nurturing and love, while fatherhood doesn't seem to be much more than a biological relationship.  As a result, men are rarely accepted if they assume a different role than the one they are "supposed to assume".

Then there are the barriers that the mothers put up:

Here's an all-too-common scenario:...their six-month-old-son started fussing.  Colin who was holding the baby began rocking him.  Suddenly his wife appeared and whisked him away.....What it seems to boil down to is that most of us--men as well as women--simply assume that women know more about kids than men....

Although most mothers feel that fathers should play an important role in the kids' lives, research has shown that they want that role to be not quite as important as the mom's.  In fact researchers have found that two out of three women seem threatened by equal participation and may themselves be subtly putting a damper on men's involvement with their children because they are so possessive of their role as primary nurturer.

  • ::

Suggestions for dads to overcome this include not handing the baby over to mom the minute he starts crying and getting involved in the day-to-day decisions such as meals, shopping, playdates.  The authors also suggest trying to find a new fathers' support group or starting one of your own.  I remember a post on our local parenting website from a mom looking for such a group for her hubby and how that poster was mercilessly teased (stuff like 'as long as there is a football game on and some beer my DH will be there'!).

I have to admit, I am quite possessive of my role as the primary decision-maker, although I am more than willing to share the day-to-day caregiving.  When it comes to the decisions, (examples: to preschool or not to preschool, to use a crib or not, we haven't gotten to the big-kid decisions yet) I would say that my input carries a heavier weight in the decision.

I'm not sure why this is.  From what I see, whether they work outside the home or not, moms seem to be the ones making most of the decisions, reading the parenting books, doing the research, talking with other moms. Some decisions ride on the mom more than the dad, whether socially or biologically speaking (whether to continue working or not, infant feeding etc.).  But what about everything else?

Could it be that fathers just aren't as interested in the details related to childrearing?  Perhaps it is some nature thing, that mothers are more in tune?  Maybe mothers like to be in charge?  

On the other hand, if the father of your baby lets you make such decisions, maybe this means that he respects you and trusts your judgement?  Maybe it's a compliment?

Tags: dads, roles (all tags)

View Comments | 55 comments