Mother Talkers

SAT Prep For Three-Year-Olds?

Tue Dec 04, 2007 at 07:28:11 AM PDT

In the dog-eat-dog world of competitive parenting, many parents are going so far as to send their three and four-year-olds to learning centers or hire private tutors to prepare them for kindergarten, according to an article in Parenting magazine.

The trend is fueled by a tutoring industry targeting young children and parents’ fears surrounding high-stakes testing in elementary school, the magazine said. And if you think this trend is restricted to elite urbanites, think again: these tutoring centers are popping up in rural areas and suburbs, too.

"When my daughter started first grade, some kid at her table called her a 'toddler' because she couldn't read," says Virginia Shea of Sunnyvale, California. Turns out her reading level was completely age-appropriate, but some of her classmates had been given a head start.

Before you freak out that your child isn’t receiving reading and math drills -- or maybe not -- all the experts interviewed by the magazine said there is no evidence that such early learning has an impact on future academic success.

”I have yet to see any statistics that prove that teaching reading and math to very little kids makes a long-term difference in their academic careers,” says Michael Thompson, Ph.D., coauthor of Raising Cain and The Pressured Child. “Just because a child can read in kindergarten doesn’t mean he’ll be a better reader in fourth grade.” Also, says Thompson, “a reward-based academic program can make kids anxious. You start seeing stomachaches, headaches, acting out, and sleep issues. Is it that important to teach four-year-olds that it’s a dog-eat-dog world?”

That said, not all children will react this way. Some kids might even thrive in this kind of achievement-based program. And just as there is no evidence that early academics do any good, there’s likewise no evidence they do any harm.

Whew! Here is another opinion by a former admissions officer at an elite private elementary school, which at least in the Bay Area, I also blame for fueling parental angst:

  • ::

”These programs may teach phonics and math facts, but that only gives what I call ‘the illusion of confidence,’” says Laurel Zimmermann, who, as the former director of admissions at Elisabeth Morrow School, a rigorous private elementary school in Englewood, New Jersey, saw firsthand both the rise of preschool tutoring programs and their results in children applying to the school. “Parents could come in and say to me, ‘My child is doing so well in his tutoring program,’ but what I would find was that the child’s creative thinking was not doing so well. And I have seen absolutely no correlation between whether a child’s gotten tutoring and how well he would do on our admissions tests.”

I would hate to see the reactions of parents whose four-year-olds don’t make it into Elisabeth Morrow. An admissions test? What could they possibly ask!

Thankfully, the magazine ran a sidebar of what exactly children need to know to enter kindergarten. Rest assured, it isn’t much so you can put away your checkbook:

The social and emotional skills that will allow her to learn and to navigate life in a classroom. Includes such things as being able to share and take turns, and knowing how to work in a group and wait for short periods of time while someone else speaks.
A good command of at least one language, whether English, Spanish, Vietnamese -- whatever the family speaks at home.
At least ten letters. Recognizing all the letters of the alphabet is great, but around half of them is a good start. He should know that print carries meaning and how to “do the book” -- that is, how to open it and go from left to right and top to bottom.
Numbers up to at least ten -- and the ability to recognize those numbers.
The ability to write her name (doesn’t have to be neat).
Some letter sounds and an ability to rhyme. She should be able to identify some words that start with the same letter sound.

Tags: reading, math, preschool, tutoring, learning center, admissions test, kindergarten, kindergarten readiness (all tags)

View Comments | 26 comments