Mother Talkers

Comments to breastfeeding moms

Thu May 01, 2008 at 06:28:51 AM PDT

I bf DD for about 14 months, until about 8 months ago.  While I didn't nurse in public often, sometimes it was necessary.  In principle, I knew we had a right to bf and people who didn't like it could piss off.  In practice, despite being as discreet as possible, I always felt conspicuous and embarrassed.  I never heard any rude comments, just a few dirty looks here and there.  

Before I breastfed, I didn't pay attention to moms in this position.  Now, of course, I have a whole new awareness about breastfeeding moms in public.  When I see one, I wonder if I should show my solidarity.  Should I smile as I walk by?  Should I say something encouraging to her?  If so, what?  I think I would have liked this, as my tension was due to being worried that strangers were going to be hostile or judging me.  Maybe if someone had said, "good job, I know that's hard to do," I would have relaxed a bit.  But maybe others want to be left the hell alone to nurse in peace.  

So what do y'all think?  Should progressive moms show solidarity to public bf moms? How?

Poll

How should progressive moms support public breastfeeders?

0%0 votes
18%13 votes
43%31 votes
38%28 votes

| 72 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: public breastfeeding (all tags)

Permalink | 34 comments

  • I think it's fine to show your solidarity! (0 / 0)

    I think I would have appreciated an occasional smile or wink or "Good for you" from another mom.

    If a guy was walking by, smiling and winking at me during my bf-ing moment, I think I would have been creeped out, though! LOL!

  • I would say something encouraging to ANY mom (0 / 0)

    feeding an infant in public whether it was breastfed or bottlefed.  Struggling with an infant in public is hard when you're new at it. I remember once struggling to change liza in a public restroom and a nice older woman say "oh honey you're doing great, it will get easier!"  I've never forgotten that.  I'd give a nice smile to any mom no matter how they were feeding their child.

    • good point (0 / 0)

      That's a good point.  All new moms need encouragement.

    • Yes. (0 / 0)

      If I see someone struggling to contain a small child in a grocery store or try to quieten a fussy infant, I try to let them know in some way that I've been there, too, and that it does get better.

      • I also try to comment to moms whose kids (0 / 0)

        are really well behaved -- sometimes in a coffee shop or store I'll say "oh your son/daughter has been so good" and then usually ad "my daughter Was NEVER that good -- EVER"  (which is true)

        • That's good, too. (0 / 0)

          Because when you're new at the whole parenting thing, you can almost swear that every place you go is filled with those who don't like being around children.  It's very nice to hear anything that reminds you that children are "normal".

        • That's a good one (0 / 0)

          One time on  plane at the end of the ride a couple people told us our kids were so well-behaved.  What a great mommy-warm-fuzzy that gave me, especially when we were so stressed out trying to travel and keep them entertained so they wouldn't cause problems.  And hey, we didn't even drug them up with benadryl!  ;)

  • Advocate where possible, or smile as you go by (0 / 0)

    A friendly smile is usually the option I take.  But about a year ago I was boarding a very full flight and they were limiting the last few boarders to one carry-on.  I sweet-talked my way through it as my bags were small, but the woman behind me nearly started crying as she explained that one bag was her laptop, and the other was her breast pump.  They tried to make her choose and so I stopped and explained/bs'ed that the breast pump was a medical device and as such they couldn't take it from her -- it would be like taking a diabetic's testing supplies and insulin.  They let her get on with both.  

    --R

  • I don't know that there is a right answer (0 / 0)

    here.  A few years ago I asked the same question to a message board and got both "smiling is good" and "don't even look at me when I'm nursing" answers.   Some women feel good when people say "hang in there" and others want you to mind your own business and pretend they don't exist.  

    I say do whatever you want.   Although I would stop at the "sit next to them and shield them" answer because I don't think we ought to shield ourselves or run and hide when we're feeding our babies.  

    A lady at playgroup was complaining that there were only 2 nursing rooms at Disneyworld when they visited recently.   I said "anywhere you can sit down is a nursing room in my opinion".   Of course, anything flat is also a change table in my opinion.   And anything non-plastic can be used as an ashtray.  

    "As God is my witness, I thought turkeys could fly"

    by lonestar canuck on Thu May 01, 2008 at 07:39:05 AM PDT

  • I usually smile, (0 / 0)

    and sometimes I might just casually say "what a beautiful baby".  

  • If they are struggling to (0 / 0)

    cover themselves, whilst holding a toddler with one hand and getting baby-latched with the other, I think its okay to offer some assistance.

    If you have a pal that is a new BF Mom its nice to go with her when she BFs. I spent a lot of time in dressing rooms, bathrooms, ladies lounges, parked cars with my friends so we could still keep socializing and she could taker her time.

  • I love when people say hi (0 / 0)

    or whatever.  Sometimes I'll just make a point to comment on the cute baby (ask the age or whatever)...not specifically mentioning the nursing but having a "normal" conversation.

    Othertimes, I'll say "They eat ALL-THE-TIME, don't they?  My 5 month old still nurses every 3 hours!"

  • Depends on the person (0 / 0)

    When I'm struggling, I prefer to be left alone so I can figure things out.  When I'm not, I'm open.  Since you have no idea when a stranger's preferences are, I say do what you want.

    My problem is, since I've been nursing a long time, I know a lot of great nursing spots.  Spots I would have loved to know about when I was a new mom.  Sometimes I want to tell a struggling nursing mom I see sitting on a bench about them, but I don't know if "There's a marvelous nursing lounge!" might come off as "Um....there's a marvelous nursing lounge."  Make sense?  

    • it would be (0 / 0)

      great if someone could create a website where all the nifty nursing spots are listed for each area. both sanctioned and self-created spots. what a resource for new moms, even ones who bottlefeed, to have a comfy spot to go to, and know about it ahead of time.

      We cannot defend freedom abroad by deserting it at home. - E.R. Murrow

      by lorin on Fri May 02, 2008 at 12:15:27 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    • how about for the dads? (0 / 0)

      I mean, obviously, dads can't bf, but how about for dads trying to give a bottle to a fidgety baby? The big department store in downtown Melbourne, Meyer, has a great nursing/baby change room (really comfy. I used it with Jess), but it's attached to the ladies' room! I used to occasionally see dads in there trying to feed or change their kids and some of them looked uncomfortable, like they'd snuck into forbidden territory. Didn't help that the whole room was furnished in shades of pink!

  • I'm just a friendly beast (0 / 0)

    so I smile at most moms anyway. I do feel solidarity with breastfeeding moms, but I get all warm and fuzzy at seeing a bottle-feeding mom, too. I'm also likely to pipe in and talk to a fussy child in the grocery lines as well, though. Kids are usually so shocked to hear my accent that they'll usually quit the fussing for a least a couple of minutes. Funnily enough, Jess is aping me on that - the other day, we were in front of a mom with year-old twin boys, and both were kind of niggly. I was cooing and waving, and Jess goes "don't worry, little fellas, it's going to be oooooo-kay." We all just about died laughing.

Permalink | 34 comments