Mother Talkers

Movie Review: La Misma Luna (Under the Same Moon)

Tue Apr 08, 2008 at 05:42:57 AM PDT

Here's my most important advice should you see this film: Bring Kleenex.

So I like a good tearjerker as much as the next gal, but I really thought my sobbing-at-the-movies days were far behind me. After all, I'm no longer a melodramatic teenager...I'm a grown-ass woman!

But when a movie revolves around the painful, wrenching separation of a mother from her son and his against-all-odds Dickensian quest to reunite with her, all bets are off.

The Mexican film La Misma Luna is the story of 9-year-old Carlitos, played by the astonishing Adrian Alonso. His mother Rosario (famed telenovela actress Kate del Castillo) is one of the estimated millions of Latinas who have left children behind in Latin American countries in order to come here, legally and illegally, and make enough money to feed said children.

Carlitos and his mother have been separated more than four years when tragedy spurs the boy's decision to cross the border, alone, armed with nothing more than an address to find his mother. The resulting journey is by turns dangerous and blessed, fearful and joyous. The lump in your throat remains long after the last, mesmerizing frame.

The narrative puts an achingly human spin on the hot-button topic of illegal immigration. While the melodramatic twists and turns verge on maudlin, it's refreshing to see a multi-faceted portrayal of illegal immigrants, and the compelling, desperate reasons why so many of them come here. It's a welcome break from the rhetoric spewed by the Lou Dobbs and Minutemen of the world. Their law-and-order argument is a perfectly contrasted black-and-white; movies like this fill in those crucial shades of gray by depicting the daily indignities immigrants face, and why they feel they have no choice.

  • ::

This movie struck a personal chord with me because my Mexican grandmother was the first member of my immediate family to immigrate; my grandfather died suddenly, leaving her with four young children and another on the way. She eventually made the unfathomable decision to leave her kids behind and come to California, where she worked as a nanny while supporting her children back in Mexico. All five children eventually joined her, one by one.

She came here legally, so I take comfort in knowing that was one less layer of pain and fear she had to endure. She passed away in 2002; I regret never asking her about her impossible decision, but the truth is I can't imagine how I would have broached such a subject with my stoic Abuelita. Now that I'm a mother I can't even conceive of leaving my daughter behind, but I am certain I will never know the desperation that drove my grandmother across the border. This movie reminded me to be thankful for that (and for my grandmother's sacrifice), each and every day.

What do you think of tearjerkers, ladies: yea or nay? Are sad stories about motherhood particularly difficult for you to watch?

Epilogue: Whatever you do, DO NOT go to Barnes & Noble right after watching this movie and flip through "I'll Love You Forever" for the first time. All the recent talk on MT sparked my curiosity but oy...talk about unfortunate timing. Sniff.

Tags: movie, review, under the same moon, immigration, tearjerker (all tags)

Permalink | 14 comments

  • Erika (0 / 0)

    Maybe you're pregnant!  You're a heap of blubbering sobs.... ;-)

    Anyway, is this movie based on a non-fiction book by journalist?  I heard a woman interviewed on Radio Times on WHYY last year who wrote a book about these children and it was heart-wrenching.

    Ugh.

  • Sad stories about parenthood (0 / 0)

    are particularly difficult for me to watch. I don't think I will ever be able to watch "Sophie's Choice" again, although I saw it several times before I was a parent.

    "Life is Beautiful" left me a in a blubbering puddle in the aisle of the theater. My kids were toddlers, I think, at the time.

    This movie sounds really good but I guess I won't know if it has a tragic ending unless I see it. So, not sure if I am up for it.

    • Ooof (0 / 0)

      I know the story, but I will never see or read "Sophie's Choice".  Ariel Gore tells a story about being alone and pregnant as a teenager in Italy.  A telegram arrived from her mother in California that simply read "DON"T READ SOPHIE'S CHOICE."

      I loved "Life is Beautiful", but I didn't have kids yet.

    • I won't give away the ending... (0 / 0)

      ...I will just say it's worth watching. :-)

  • Forget seeing the film (0 / 0)

    just the review has me in tears.

  • I've seen the trailers (0 / 0)

    And I teared up there!  I'm not sure I could handle the movie.  And that's definitely an attitude I've developed since becoming a parent.  I also think for me personally, any mother-son thing hits me twice as hard.  I can't bear to think of my sweet little boy out there on his own.

    I saw "Sophie's Choice" many years ago, and now I've got that central scene in my mind.  I think I'll need to go do something happy.

  • Sniffle (0 / 0)

    Wow.  I can't even imagine.

  • I can't deal. (0 / 0)

    I laugh hard, play hard, eat hard, and cry hard. I can't deal with emotional movies, but especially when the plot has anything to do with a child. I have to prepare myself and the timeing has to be right; I can't be menstrual, that's for sure.

    My job exposes me to many moms/dads that live hear and have children in their home country. Sadly, I also see families who get seperated by INS.

    My mom came here (legally) in the late 70's from Mexico. She left us with my Abuelita and would visit us once a year. She came for my sister and I when I was 7 (she left when I was 1); I remember being amazed because the sidewalk sparkled.

    Great review Erika, I can't wait to see the film.

  • Oh, I'm such a blubbering mess now (0 / 0)

    at parent themes. I mean, I bawled my eyes out at the end of the last Harry Potter!

    Last real tear-jerker movie - Rabbit Proof Fence, based on a true story of three Aboriginal girls who were taken from their mothers (part of the Stolen Generation) and put in an institutionalised orphanage. The oldest one runs away with the other two and attempts to find their family by walking across outback Australia following a fence. I was just a mess.

  • I went to see the movie today... (0 / 0)

    and I can't stop thinking about it. It was very difficult to watch, as Cristian is the same age as this boy in the movie was that crossed the border (in Texas), and traveled from Texas to California to find his mother.

    Along the way, he meets his father in Tucson. He had recently learned of his existance and asked for his help. At one point, his "father" asked how long his mother had been "en el otro lado" (on the other side), at which point Carlitos said, "four years". The "father" expressed his disappointment and said that four years was too long to be away from her son. When Carlitos responded with "Yes, but it's not as long as you..." I CHEERED!!

    I took my mother, who lived in Los Angeles (by herself), while my father and older brother and sisters lived in Tijuana. She cleaned houses and ironed for other people in order to send money back home. This movie touched me on so many different levels. I felt it was true to life regarding the struggles that a lot of immigrants go through in order to provide a better life for their families. When Carlitos asked why his mother was "on the other side" without him, he was told "Don't you think she would rather be with you? Do you think anybody wants THIS life?" Of course, he was referring to running from "la migra" (INS), doing hard labor for pennies, working under unsafe conditions at "la pisca" (field work), just to be able to provide for your family. There was a lot to think about.

    At one point during the movie, I listened to the lyrics of a song playing in the background...it was pretty interesting. It's about the different in treatment between "Superman", and "un mojado" (a wet back or Mexican), being that they're BOTH illegal...interesting.

    Superman's An Illegal

    (Spoken) It's a bird!
    It's a plane!
    No, man, it's a wetback!
    (Sung)
    He came from the sky tucked in a spaceship.
    From Krypton to Earth was such a long trip.
    We've one thing in common: we managed to skip
    Requesting American citizenship.
    You know there are laws about immigration
    and he simply lacks his documentation.
    So how can he work as a newspaper man?
    By rights he should be locked up in the can.
    But he's blue-eyed, tall and muy lovey-dovey;
    I'm dark-skinned, short and a little bit chubby.
    He got in for free but I had to pay.
    Coyotes ain't cheap but they sure know the way.
    Ain't impersonating a cop still a crime?
    As far as the draft, he never had time.
    Don't have no license to fly like a rocket!
    No social security card in his pocket.
    The man's got to go and this ain't a joke.
    He's stealing a job from American folk.
    Or let Lady Liberty send out the word;
    Aliens here have to fly like a bird.

    Touché!!

Permalink | 14 comments