Mother Talkers

Child Slave Labor in China

Thu May 01, 2008 at 08:10:20 AM PDT

Cross-posted at Fussbucket

If toxic paint wasn't enough of a reason to boycott toys made in China, an article in today's NY Times says that hundreds and maybe thousands of children in China have been sold to work as slave laborers in booming coastal factory cities.

Authorities in southern Guangdong Province, near Hong Kong, said they had already rescued more than 100 children from factories in Dongguan, a huge manufacturing city known for producing and exporting toys, textiles and electronics.  The children, mostly 13 to 15 years old, were often tricked or kidnapped by employment agencies working in an impoverished part of western Sichuan Province, and then sent to factory towns in Guangdong, where they were often forced to work as much as 300 hours a month for little money, according to government officials and accounts from the state-owned media.

The new child labor case “is quite typical,” said Hu Xingdou, a professor of economics and social policy at the Beijing Institute of Technology. “China’s economy is developing at a fascinating speed, but often at the expense of laws, human rights and environmental protection.” Professor Hu also said that sometimes the children were sold by their parents who didn't know of the working conditions.

  • ::

The child labor scandal was uncovered by Southern Metropolis Daily, a crusading newspaper based in Guangzhou, in southern China, less than a year after the authorities said they had rescued hundreds of people, including children, from working as “slave laborers” in brick kilns in the north and central part of the country.  Many of the workers in that case also said they had been kidnapped.

Young people can legally go to work in factories when they turn 16, the article says. In a series of articles this week, the Southern Metropolis Daily said recruiters and labor agencies working in Liangshan often transported children south and then “sold” them to factories at virtual auctions in Guangdong Province, one of China’s biggest manufacturing centers and home to a huge population of migrant workers.  At some coastal factories, children were even lined up and selected based on their body type, the journalists wrote.

The newspaper also alleged that when the children were paid, they received about three renminbi per hour, or about 43 cents, far below the local minimum wage, about 64 cents an hour. By law, overtime pay is much higher.

The Chinese paper said that some children had been threatened with death if they tried to escape from labor recruiters.  The newspaper did not identify the coastal factories where the children worked, but the report said that one was a toy factory in Dongguan.

Okay, what the hell? This is horrible. I don't even know what to say. Anyone?

Tags: China, toys and child labor, forced child labor in China, boycott toys made in China (all tags)

Permalink | 8 comments

  • i feel sick (0 / 0)

    whenever i read about child and slave labor i feel sick.

    my kids already tell people not to buy things made in china- my mom thinks it's cute that ali asked for apple juice not made in china

    it's so hard, but it has really slowed down our consumption.  for the last birthday parties my kids went to the gifts we gave were arts and craft supplies- all made in the usa or canada.

    i'm sick of it- i'm not giving those monsters another cent- i don't care how cute the toy is or how pretty the clothes are.

    in the store my kids still ask why i won't buy certain things- like there is an outdoor playhouse at costco they really want.  i just explain to them the factory owners treat the workers very badly and i won't give them any of our money.

  • sick (0 / 0)

    I can't even read stuff like this, it makes me so sick.  

  • why I don't boycott child labor (0 / 0)

    My grandmother was the oldest of 5; she had to leave school at age 12 to work in a factory after her father disappeared.  This was in the US, before the social safety net, and you did what you had to do.  She went on to have a good life.

    China is where the US was when my grandmother was a girl, and it has a long way to go to reach western standards.  In the above article what I see is Chinese authorities cracking down on abuses, freeing children, and enforcing minimum wage standards.  The story is reported as a scandal, not business as usual.  I know little about China but I can at least hope that this means things are getting better.

    People seem to think that if American consumers put enough "pressure" on manufacturers, child labor will vanish and the kids will all go to school.  That's not true in many if not most developing countries.  A family forced to put their child to work is unlikely to have the school fees once the child is unemployed.  I've heard of villages where school is part of the day, and is paid for out of wages earned during the other part.  And I know a child who was put up for adoption after a textile plant closed.

    So I consider child labor apart from the more serious abuses, and don't judge.  Everybody wants what's best for their children.  Sometimes what's best is education, but sometimes it's food.  We're lucky to not face such choices.  

    • interesting (0 / 0)

      It does seem to me that if you are opposed to forced labor of children that one way to express that is to refuse buy the products that those kids are being forced to make. Of course, we don't know exactly which toys were made under these conditions. On a visceral level, I can't stand the thought that my kids might be playing with toys that were made by other children who were suffering.

      But I hear your point that the issue may be more complicated than simply boycotting products made in China.

      • no morally clean choice (0 / 0)

        I don't like it either.  But for the most part these children are there because it is their best option.  You don't help people by taking away their best option.

        I think it was Jeffrey Sach's book that opened my eyes to the major limiting problem of developing countries, access to capital and access to markets.  So I buy the products, providing the market.  I donate to a charity that does microfinance, providing a little capital.  But I have reached the sad conclusion that a clean conscience is a luxury that I may not have a right to in an inequitable world.

  • re: child labor in China (0 / 0)

    I look across the living room at my 2 little girls, 8 and a half and 2 and a half, one stringing beads and the other doing homework, and i want to throw up. BTW, they are both from China.

    Unfortunately, child labor is a fact of life in many countries-where there is poverty & a lack of educational opportunities for men and women (but especially women), there will be children sold into sexual slavery in Thailand, to rug makers in India, and to kiln factories and other places in China.

    What WE can do, at the very least, is vote with our wallets by ID-ing where certain items come from and then NOT BUYING THEM.

    And that's a pitiful drop in the bucket.

  • There are some US companies in China (0 / 0)

    that are cooperating with an international agency by certifying they have safe and humane work practices. An independet agency coems in to review them and make sure the people are not being exploited. So I also check that as well as country of origin.

  • Sickening (0 / 0)

    I remember reading about this in Mothering Magazine a few years ago.  Here's an excerpt from that article:

    The vast majority of plastic commercial toys are made by children themselves, working in overseas sweatshops. Girls as young as 13 years, some working the night shift, stitch Barbie's dresses.2 In Thailand in 1993, hundreds of workers, including child laborers, died in a fire while stuffing Cabbage Patch dolls for Hasbro, Inc.3 The Asia Monitor Resource Center and the Coalition for the Charter on the Safe Production of Toys reported that Vietnamese workers making McDonald's Happy Meals toys for as little as six cents an hour had been poisoned by acetone, a chemical solvent used to manufacture plastic Disney characters such as the 101 Dalmatians line.4 All of this so that I can pull up to the drive-through window and toss my child a Happy Meal figurine? No, thanks.

    So sad.  We as consumers can boycott all we want, but I agree it's a drop in the bucket.  Policies need to change.  It's a good thing that it's hitting the mainstream media.

    "If it's not Scottish, it's crap!" ~Mike Meyers

    by 1plain1peanut on Fri May 02, 2008 at 06:15:29 AM PDT

Permalink | 8 comments