Mother Talkers

Pet Food Contamination May Have Killed in 2004

Thu Mar 06, 2008 at 10:20:29 AM PDT

A new study from the Journal of Veterinary Diagnostic Investigation suggests that melamine-tainted pet foods may have been behind a large dieoff of pets in 2004 in asian countries. It was written off as coincidence ("Our popular dog foods are fed to a lot of old, sick animals"), or possible mycotoxin.

Hat tip to the Pet Connection Blog:

The Journal of Veterinary Investigative Diagnosis reported that the Asian cases were initially attributed to contamination with mycotoxin, and that “an estimated 6,000 dogs and a smaller number of cats developed nephrotoxic renal failure in 2004.” But their own research, working with tissue samples from animals from both years discovered characteristic crystals and kidney damage typical of melamine-associated renal failure (MARF) caused by the ingestion of melamine and cyanuric acid:

This study provides compelling evidence that the pet food–associated renal failure outbreaks in 2004 and 2007 share causation. In particular, the outbreaks share identical clinical, histologic, and toxicologic findings. Given the unique nature of the histologic features and the specificity of the toxicologic tests in this study, it is reasonable to conclude that both are examples of MARF. Although the source of melamine and cyanuric acid responsible for the 2007 MARF outbreak has been identified as vegetable protein concentrates imported from China, the source in the 2004 outbreak remains undetermined.

[….]

The addition of melamine, cyanuric acid, or both to enhance apparent protein content of vegetable concentrates is reportedly commonplace in some regions. Because chronic interstitial fibrosis is a self-perpetuating process and a common finding in animals with chronic kidney disease, sublethal MARF could represent an important, previously unrecognized cause of chronic kidney disease in dogs and cats. Interestingly, the contaminated wheat gluten in the 2007 outbreak was a human food–grade product. The potential effects of ingestion of similarly contaminated material by people are unknown.

This makes a lot of sense to me - there was no reason to think the practice was new - but it's also disturbing in how widespread it may have been, and leaves open the idea that a lot of animals have had their health subtly damaged by melamine for a very long time. Not to mention, of course, what's in our own food supply.

Time to get to work in the garden!

  • ::

Tags: pet food, melamine, food safety (all tags)

Permalink | 7 comments

  • Thanks for sharing this (0 / 0)

    It makes perfect sense that last year's poisoned food was not new. What a mess! Of course I had no pets for the longest time and then got my two kitties just two months before all of this came out. Thankfully they were ok and I've since only fed them Life's Abundance all natural food from Trilogy online - got the recommendation form a Dkos diary when all the news was swirling around and people were exchanging alternative food sources. The cats love it and they are healthy which is what matters!

  • Gawd that's sad (0 / 0)

    Pets really are a part of our family.  I'd be devastated if I lost my dog because of tainted food.  Terrible that this is so widespread.

  • I really worry about the human supply. (0 / 0)

    There are no US producers of gluten - they all went out of business, they can't produce it cheaply enough. So all the gluten in the US food supply is imported, I think most if not all from China. Is anyone testing it for this stuff? Nah. Not, of course, that US companies are immune. There was an Ohio based industrial fish feed producer in September of last year who were busted for doing the melamine thing (barely made the news - did that story not fit the barely audible media narrative or something?). It just all shows that we need better regulation and testing of our food supplies.
    We actually use Seitan, a wheat gluten product, as a protein in the veggie curry we make at home. I keep wondering if I ought to send a sample to get it tested.

    "You're never more alone than when you're alone in a crowd."

    by Expat Briton on Thu Mar 06, 2008 at 11:29:12 AM PDT

  • so sad (0 / 0)

    It does make a lot of sense; these things don't just randomly appear overnight. Somebody gets randomly caught, things are adjusted temporarily and then back to business as usual. Geez, I hate to think of animals being slowly and subtly damaged over a long period of time - being in pain or just not right and not being able to communicate it. Damn.

    I've always been careful of what we eat, but even more so now that these food safety issues have come to the fore. Produce and packaging labeling is better here in Australia than in the US (for example, it is a requirement that all produce have country-of-origin labelling), but it's still not perfect. For example, the other day I was debating between two types of tinned passionfruit pulp. One was "Made in Australia", the other was "Made of Australian and imported fruit." It didn't say where the imported fruit was from. Neither can said where the pulp was processed and canned. I went for the "Made in Australia" one, but I still have my suspicions. So next year I'm getting a passionfruit vine!

Permalink | 7 comments