Mother Talkers

Should We Secure Our Schools?

Sun Mar 30, 2008 at 07:11:36 AM PDT

When I read the lead of this story, my initial reaction was to shudder at the thought of sending my kids to a Chicago public school. A record number of students have been killed -- largely by gunfire -- in Chicago that the city is taking aggressive steps like installing security cameras in the schools, according to the Associated Press.

Since September, 20 Chicago Public Schools students have been killed, 18 by gunfire. Last school year, 24 of the more than 30 students killed were shot to death, compared with between 10 and 15 fatal shootings in the years before...

The number of violent deaths involving students in the nation's third-largest school district has increased so dramatically in the last two years that police are increasing school patrols and soon will be the first department in the country with live access to thousands of security cameras mounted outside — and inside — schools.

While the students say they feel safe at the school with its beefed up security, I could not help but think they were protected by a false sense of security. As the article later pointed out, none of the murders actually happened at the school. It sounds like the killings are more emblematic of the spike in violent crime in the city rather than lax patrolling of the schools.

Daley recently announced a new resource for police — access to the 4,500 security cameras mounted inside and outside about 200 elementary and high schools.

The real-time video from the cameras once was available only to school officials, but now police and the city's Office of Emergency Management and Communications will be able to see it as well. Daley said indoor cameras will be used only in emergencies.

Daley also has rolled back the curfew times for minors by half an hour, to 10 p.m. on weekdays and 11 p.m. on weekends.

Many observers insist the issue isn't a school problem but a symptom of overall violence in the city. In fact, students in some of the city's most violent neighborhoods say school — with metal detectors, private security guards and uniformed police officers — is the one place they feel safe.

  • ::

Homicide, BTW, is the second-leading cause of death for people between the ages of 10 and 24, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Eighty-one percent were killed with a firearm in 2004, according to the CDC.

Do you think the city is making the most use of its funds by monitoring the schools? If you were Mayor Daley, how would you handle the increase in violent crime among the city's youth?

Poll

Chicago should invest in...

12%4 votes
41%13 votes
32%10 votes
12%4 votes

| 31 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: murder rate, Chicago, security camera, guns, high school, Associated Press (all tags)

Permalink | 2 comments

  • safer at school (0 / 0)

    I did my student teaching in a high-poverty high school in Chicago last year, and I actually agree with the idea that the kids feel safer at school than anywhere else.

    My school in particular had a pretty palpable gang presence, but there was little to no gang fighting inside the school. It was generally understood that the  kids who got into fights over gang stuff at school were the ones who weren't really serious - they "wanted" to get caught. Getting caught meant they would be suspended, which was fine by them. By contrast, fighting outside of school and NOT getting caught meant someone would probably get killed.

    I'd be much more interested in seeing economic relief for high-poverty areas, increased police presence in high-crime areas and social services in the neighborhoods to try to correct these problems. I think they really aren't indicative of problems in the schools so much as they are of problems in the city as a whole.

  • I don't know. (0 / 0)

    Like Diane posted above, it doesn't address the real problem, does it?  And honestly, I hate the feel that our schools are being turned into what feels like security facilities.  Ok...you have the cameras...how are they really going to be used?  Are they going to be used as a safety measure against violent crime, or are they going to be used to treat a kid walking the hall when he should be in class as if he/she were a dangerous criminal?

    In our city, all of our schools have a police officer.  It sounds good...and truthfully, some of them have been great, including a neighbor of mine who went the next step and started outreach and study groups for students.  However, in many schools, this has served to turn discipline problems into "criminal acts"...and I don't think that's good.  

Permalink | 2 comments