Mother Talkers

When the Elderly Outnumber the Young

Fri Mar 14, 2008 at 11:07:27 AM PDT

A recent story in Newsweek highlighted an unfortunate -- but predictable -- side effect of China's draconian one child policy: Many elderly people are alone and they have no one to care for them.

Family is the bedrock of Chinese society, at least in theory. But three decades of gut-wrenching change are testing those old bonds. More kids than ever are leaving their hometowns—even the country—in search of jobs. This generation is the first to grow up under the one-child policy, rolled out in 1979. They are "more likely to be spoiled and self-centered," says demographics expert Cai Feng. "As adults, children of this generation lack the inclination to support their parents." Forty-two percent of Chinese families in 2005 consisted of an old couple living alone, according to the National Bureau of Statistics.

That's causing even young parents to rethink the meaning of family in China. For centuries a healthy brood of boys was considered the best form of social security. That's still generally true in the countryside; farmers prefer sons who can work in the fields over a daughter whose earning potential—if any—is transferred to her husband's family. But in China's cities, many young couples now say they prize daughters over sons for their loyalty. "Urban couples all think girls are much better than boys. Girls are more thoughtful, especially towards their parents," says Feng Xiaotian, a sociology professor at Nanjing University who has conducted surveys of Chinese families. In a recent China Youth Daily poll, respondents who preferred a daughter (29 percent) edged out those who wanted a son (28.4 percent).

To avoid loneliness, or even worse, a nursing home -- still considered shameful in Chinese society -- many elderly Chinese are "adopting" adult women as their daughters. Young, wealthy urbanites are breaking the one-child policy by having more children and paying a fine. They are also having more children through loopholes in the policy such as bearing children in another country or saying that their older children are handicapped. In the most extreme cases, men are having children by different women.

The Chinese government has no safety net for so many elderly people so it is encouraging youth to take care of their parents. "The Education Ministry has supported a resurgence of Confucian studies, which promote respect for elders," the Newsweek article stated.

This topic resonates with me as I have always been conflicted by culture clash; the American ideal of rugged individualism and the more communal attitude I was raised with by a Latino family. Like the Chinese, there are deep cultural biases against nursing homes among Latinos. My grandmother, whose mental capacities worsen by the day due to Alzheimer's, lives with my parents.

But what do you do if you live far from your family? How should the Chinese deal with this aging crisis?

  • ::

Tags: China, Newsweek, one child policy, only child, elderly, care, daughter, son (all tags)

Permalink | 5 comments

  • living it as we speak.. (0 / 0)

    we just 3 weeks ago moved my mom and step dad up to our home in oregon from our house here in bay area.  3 years ago we emergency moved them here as my mother's health was dire.  long story,but we got her compeletly back on her feet and they wanted to live independently again back in oregon. we are readying our home here to sell...

    yesterday however we had to emergency fly her back down due to an illness that none of us could adequately ascertain the extent of the problem via phone.

    we are in the throes of what to do.  my solution is to hire a health care "nanny" for them in oregon.  it is not easy having parents live with you as physically,at least in our case, they thrived.  but they sure weren't happy. these are tough decisions and very  complex.

    • wow (0 / 0)

      Best of luck on working through all this.  As you say, these are tough decisions.

      • thanks all.. (0 / 0)

        just got back from seeing my mom and step dad with one of my brothers. the emotions are full and steep, let me tell you...for all of us.  but the good news is we made significant headway.  my mom got back in to see her doc at kaiser today and she is ok.  she needs physical therapy NOT drugs. i love kaiser, they aren't perfect, but they have a uniformed whole approach that doesn't resort to loading old folks up on drugs.  we are flying her and my step dad back up to oregon tomorrow. and she has agreed in theory to a health care assitant. now we just have to find one.
    • Wow, Melinda... (0 / 0)

      Well wishes to you and your family. I agree that this is one of the toughest stages in life. ((Hugs))

  • Not sure about the Chinese (0 / 0)

    but this is going on, I believe, to a large extent here.  In North Dakota, my home state, the over-65 population greatly exceeds any other age group.  Besides the fact that ND is definitely a state where the majority of the young leave as soon as possible (myself included), they can't build senior living centers fast enough, and can't find enough people to staff them.  About eight weeks ago, my mom & her sisters were faced with the decision about what to do with my grandma, who is 86, and was living alone in a rather large house.  She's been having mini-strokes & her doctor finally said she could not be alone.  

    One of my aunts lives in the same town, but her health is poor as well, so she was not up to taking care of Grandma full-time.  The nearest assisted living center we could find with a vacancy was in a town 60 miles away.  Luckily, one of my other aunts lives there, and my grandma has enough money to be able to pay for it, but it's been a hard adjustment.  She lived in her house for nearly 30 years, and in that town for nearly 60. I can only imagine what it will be like for my generation trying to help the Baby Boomers, who outnumber us almost 2:1.

Permalink | 5 comments