Mother Talkers

Some of the best kids' books

Thu Feb 28, 2008 at 10:57:21 AM PDT

This is a fun diary as there are so many avid readers on this site. Thanks for the list, Katherine! -Elisa

In the past 7.5 years I have waded through an awful lot of crap in the name of getting my kids to enjoy reading.  And it has worked - they are both big readers (the older one independently; my 4 year old still relies on us to read out loud to him).  But not every moment has been a song of joy.  There is a lot of junk out there, and some gold nuggets among the sea of junk.

I'd be interested to hear what you and your kids have really enjoyed.  Below I list several of the books we have loved, and some we've hated.

I have two boys, ages 4 and 7.5.

Some of the ones we like:

Harry Potter by J.K. Rowling.  So much to discuss and think about; a high degree of complexity in plot and characters for a kids' book.

The A to Z Mysteries by Ron Roy.  Much simpler than Harry Potter but an appealing, smart, nice group of 3 spunky kids who go around their Connecticut town (and occasionally farther) solving mysteries.  Occasionally scary to my kids, but mostly ok.  He also has a new series called the Capital Mysteries which I think is not quite as good but still worth reading.

Half Magic by Edward Eager (and other Edward Eager books).  I remember loving this book as a kid and I just got it and read it to my boys.  They absolutely LOVED it.  It's about a family of four children who discover a magic amulet that provides half of what you wish for (for example, the boy wishes to be on a desert island and they end up in the desert instead).  It's thoughtful and funny and the kids are realistically portrayed.

Dan Gutman's Baseball Card Adventure books (Honus and Me, The Babe and Me, etc.).  If your children like baseball and history as mine do they will enjoy these books about a father and son who go back into time and meet some famous ballplayers of the past.  Well written and interesting.

Cam Jansen mysteries by David Adler.  These are about a girl with a photographic memory and her friend, a boy named Eric.  They solve various mysteries.  They can be repetitive (particularly the parts about Cam's amazing memory) but in general they're pretty entertaining.  Plus they have a "quiz" at the end where the kids get to try to remember the details in an earlier picture, which my kids like to do.

Anything by Cynthia Rylant.  These are easy readers for younger kids.  They include the Poppleton books, the Henry & Mudge books, the Mr. Putter and Tabby books, and the High Rise Private Eyes.  My kids have loved all of them.

Amber Brown books by Paula Danziger. These are good and the kids are realistic, but can be kind of depressing (Amber's parents get divorced).

Judy Moody and Stink books by Megan McDonald.  My kids LOVE these books.  They are about a brother and sister who are maybe ages 7 and 9 or so.  The books are funny and true to life.

A few I hate:

Magic Tree House series by Mary Pope Osborne.  While I appreciate the goal of these books, to introduce history and science in a child-friendly way, the writing style is so boring and repetitive that it drives me crazy to read them.

Pretty much anything about any cartoon characters (Ninja Turtles, Power Rangers, and the like).  Incredibly boring.

Please add your favorites (or hates) below!

Tags: books, reading, Harry Potter (all tags)

Permalink | 33 comments

  • Non-fiction (0 / 0)

    My girls (6 and 9) LOOOOOOOOVVVVVEEEE non-fiction. I'm not a non-fiction reader, so I wasted a lot of time reading them "stories" that they really didn't care for. I think they enjoyed Magic Treehouse because it's quasi historical; although, I share some of your criticisms of that series.

    They enjoy short biographies of historical figures, historical fiction like the American Girl series, and encyclopedia-style books.

    But they do like some fiction. Particular favorites of my 9 year old include "Whales on Stilts" by MT Anderson, "Everything on a Waffle" by Polly Horvath, and "Ruby Holler" by Sharon Creech. She also likes Roald Dahl a lot.

    She asked me the other day what the deal was with Harry Potter. "I mean, it's not even realistic!" I just looked at my shelf full of volumes 1-7 and sighed!

    Fortunately for me, they didn't care for Junie B. Jones and found her as unlikable as I did.

    • Harry Potter (0 / 0)

      My older son is similary a non-fiction kinda guy, and has tended to balk at long-form fiction.

      I was desperate to get him into them, so one night, I had a copy of Sorcerer's Stone on my nightstand and just casually said, "Say, want me to read to you?" Because he's such a strong reader and was already 7 years old, it was a treat for him to be read to, so I started in on Chapter One and by the end of it, he had grabbed it from my hand and started reading it himself. That was June and by August, he'd read the first five, then he finished the final two in September.

  • Sounds like we've got the same preferences (0 / 0)

    My boys are 5 and nearly 7.  We're waiting a bit on Harry Potter - my 5 year old isn't quite ready.  But they absolutely loved Half Magic.  Another favorite in a similar vein was Peter Graves by William Pene du Bois, so we just got another of his from the library.  

    Uncle Remus is currently top of the charts for short stories, though we usually read chapter books now.  Mr Popper's Penguins was a hit.  We're working through Beverly Cleary books - my elder son likes Henry Huggins, his brother is fond of Ramona's antics.  

    If you like Rylant I recommend Gooseberry Park.  When my boys were little the Mr Potter books were a staple.

    Any tedious novelization that contains Anakin Skywalker is a surefire hit, no matter how badly written.  And for the little guy, anything that features invention, construction, or explosion qualifies as great literature.

    I agree that Magic Treehouse falls flat.  But my boys love Time Soldiers.

    • Yes! (0 / 0)

      Those Star Wars/Clone Wars books are a hit and a huge bore.

      Thanks for the recommendations, I expect my kids would love them!

      I forgot to mention above also the Time Warp Trio.  My kids like those a lot and they are in a similar vein - historical, but funny rather than boring and repetitive like Magic Treehouse.

  • Louis Sachar!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (0 / 0)

    My son is a little older (8.5), and he loves these books - Sideways stories from the Wayside School (three in the series), and just started "Holes", which I thought was over his head, but he says "nope, I love it" - couldn't pull him away from it during the vacation!

    Also, don't forget E.B. White - Charlotte's Web is an oldie but a goodie - I thought my son wouldn't like it (I think of it as a girl book, so my bias is showing), but he loved it.  Teacher is reading "Trumpet and the Swan" to the class this month, and he loves that too.

    I like the "Magic Treehouse" books, but Seth got tired of them - probably what you said - they're repetetive.  We spend much more time on the "Research Guides" that go along with the stories. Like someone else said, my son is a big non-fiction fan.

  • Yay! (0 / 0)

    Eloise falls into both categories, because my daughter (4) and I both love it and dh hates it.

    We love the Cat in the Hat non-fiction books, such as "Inside Your Outside."

    Dr. Suess

    When she's older I'm excited about Ramona, Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle, "Peter Pan" (we're reading it now, but I think she's humoring me) and "Alice in Wonderland."

    Like others, I dislike cartoon and product themed books.  We have a My Little Pony book that actually made me vomit--every time--when i was pregnant.  Hate is a strong word for this one, but I'm not as excited about Harry Potter as most people are.  I'm okay with the books, but I'm just not into fantasy.  Go ahead and string me up.  I'm the only person I've ever heard of who doesn't like Harry Potter for non-religious reasons.

  • Liza has been into (0 / 0)

    the classics lately -- Little Women, Secret Garden, and Heidi
    but she also has started the Sisterhood of the Travelling Pants series - and the Spiderwick Chronicles series.

    she's like me - she has about 4-5 books in different stages of finishing around the house -- she gets to 'em when she gets to 'em!

    • Spiderwick (0 / 0)

      My five-year-old DS and I just finished all of these (I edited out the naughty words while I was reading). He loves them. He also has the Field Guide.

      I was somewhat underwhelmed by the characters, but all of the fantasy stuff is just great.

  • thanks for this diary (0 / 0)

    Jess, being 2 1/2, is too young for me to contribute on this one, but you can bet I'm searching it out in a few years to get inspiration!

    I'm really amazed by how many bad children's books there are. OK, so most toddlers aren't ready for War and Peace, but please, some effort on plot and characterization is necessary!

  • All By Myself and (0 / 0)

    Everybody Poops are two huge hits with my 21 mos old right now, and anything about Egypt is a hit with my 5 year old. We just got that Steven & Lucy Hawking kids book, and I think it's a little old for my 5 year old.

    The Trumpet of the Swan by E.B. White is a good chapter book, and Frog & Toad are fantastic for everyone.

    I'm amazed, but I can get away with reading Doctor Seuss and many other picture books to both of them at the same time. They really like it when I read to both of them at the same time...very fun.

  • Favorite Books (0 / 0)

    My kids are 8 and 5.

    My 8 year old daughter loves the Animal Ark books right now. She read all the Cam Jansen books, and she's also working her way through the (ugh) Mary Kate and Ashley books. We also devoured all the Wayside School books and several other of Sachar's books, though I couldn't get her into Holes.

    A few years ago, we were enjoying the Cornelia Funke picture books. Not the older fantasy novels like Inkheart etc. These were books like "Princess Knight" and some others I can't remember. We also enjoyed D'Aulaire's Book of Greek Myths. But in general, she hates fantasy books. Weird, I know! She likes mysteries and realistic fiction. And any book about cats.

    My 5 year old son loves non-fiction books, mainly about dinosaurs. He also enjoys Dr. Seuss and the Berenstain Bears (ugh to the latter).

    We all also loved Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs, the Click Clack Moo books and Frog and Toad (my husband's favorite from when he was a kid). My husband mainly reads to our son and I read to our daughter. Even though she's 8, she still enjoys being read to, though she will continue reading in bed till 9 every night.

  • Random comments (0 / 0)

    I too dislike Magic Tree House, though they seem to be fairly popular. I'm not sure if DD likes them or not; she's given me mixed signals.

    She adores The Silly Book by Stoo Hample.

    We had a lot of fun reading Slinky Malinki - the language is full of seductive, wonderful rhymes that flow off the tongue.

    She liked The School For Cats by Esther Averill, which reminds me, I should hunt for some more in that series.

    Lately she's been methodically bringing home every non-fiction horse book in the school library. I don't know whether she is genuinely only wanting to read about horses or if she just thinks they'll please me so we're more likely to read them together.

    She seems to prefer chapter books that we can read in one sitting, which is about 50 pages.

  • We have tons of Magic Treehouse (0 / 0)

    as my five-year-old went through a phase where he loved them. Happily for me, he's moved past that for the moment, because I really found them annoying. I need characters I can sink my teeth into, not pallid imitations of such!

    I am such an ecumenical reader myself and my children are both the same. My almost three-year-old likes books for kids that are much older, which is really fun because he can sit for some of the longer books so we read them all together. We all really like pretty much everything by Cynthia Rylant, especially Poppleton and Mr. Putter.

    For chapter books, I love the Moomin books - magical ones from my childhood (and especial favorite is Moominland Midwinter). We have also read some of the Little House books (they have nice picture book versions of these that both boys also enjoy).

    We recently read a series of books by Kate DiCamillo (who wrote Because of Winn-Dixie) about a pig named Mercy Watson who loves to eat hot buttered toast. These are like the Poppleton books - hybrid picture/chapter books. We all really enjoyed these - the characters in them are great and really funny.

    Anything by Jon Scieza (sp?) is a hit at our house, especially Math Curse. We also love the Time Warp Trio books.

    We read tons of nonfiction, some of dreadful and dull, some of it really interesting. For children interested in dinosaurs (my younger son's passion) the Dougal Dixon books are great - really amazing pictures and descriptions.

    I have so many books in my house that it can be hard to say sometimes what we like! Seems like we are always reading something different.

    What an awesome diary this was. I'm really excited to try those Dan Gutman books - my older son is fascinated by baseball (we've recently read some great books about Jackie Robinson and Satchel Page by David Adler) and will be starting T-ball in a few weeks. I know he will like those. Thanks for sharing!

  • so many books (0 / 0)

    a few favorites that stand out, from various years:

    the Eric Carle books when they were very small, especially Brown Bear, Brown Bear and Polar Bear, Polar Bear.

    Amazing Grace -- of course, because of my DD Grace

    Lily's Purple Plastic Purse

    The Scrambled States of America

    Where the Wild things Are

    The Phantom Tollbooth

    all the HP series

    Wrinkle in Time series

    Little House series

    Richard Riordan's Percy Jackson series

    my DD loves the American Girl doll books even though she's never had one of the dolls. She just read "Julie" who lives in that long-ago time, the 1970s!! Just like mommy did!!

Permalink | 33 comments