Mother Talkers

Travelling Amtrak

Sun Jan 27, 2008 at 09:51:09 AM PDT

"Everyone's a rail fan. Some people are just quieter about it than others."

Nevada streamThat's what a gentleman said to me when I asked him if he was a railfan. Diehards are easily recognized by their casual identification of a location that is to the casual observer, nowhere.

But I loved the truth in it. Trains are special. A road trip, the classic American vacation is fine, but the train version is far better. A dining car, the chance to walk around, no sleepy drivers, easy bathroom access - all of the inconveniences of car travel are gone. Even a familiar path is different from the tracks.

He works for Burlington Northern, and he grew up in Wyoming. So, he comes by his knowledge from more than mere fandom. He tells me that the switch we've just passed is the path to Cheyenne.  We talk about Amtrak, and the perennial battle to keep it alive in Congress. The track we're on used to be on a regular route between Denver and Seattle, but it was dropped despite ample ridership because somebody in Washington had to make a budget cut. He tells me about the towns in Wyoming that used to rely on the train in winter, that are unaccessible by road when the train can still get through. Not many people can tough it out.

Amtrak doesn't suffer from lack of ridership. What vexes it is an upfront, obvious subsidy that has to be explicitly renewed each year. Highway funding does not require reauthorization, and the need for highways is obvious even to the dullest Congressman. Airlines are barely profitable even though they don't pay for their own airports or runways. Amtrak, forced to get by on crumbs, rents time on the tracks from the freight companies, which run their cargoes first, making Amtrak trains late and slow. The tracks are functional, but they're not the sleek, smooth tracks of Europe that permit bullet speeds. Even at 50 MPH, the train rolls and jerks from side to side as it travels.

Why are we the only industrialized country without a solid passenger rail system again?

  • ::

Our detour through Wyoming is supposed to be the less pretty way, but the landscape is still dramatic. Though I've travelled all over the western United States, I've never been to Wyoming, so I'm looking forward to seeing what's out here.

We left YearlyKos via Amtrak, on the California Zephyr. What was once considered a grand building, Union Station, is now undersized and overcrowded for the amount of duty it does, in need of air conditioning and with every square foot within the terminal and food court areas in quite active use. Lines are long; their computer systems are clearly antiquated compared to what we've come to expect in an airport.

However, it is not long before we are boarding our full-to-the-brim train with a diverse assortment of other Americans.

We walk into the 'gate' and finally to our respective track, #12. It is an awesome sight to see these enormous engines up close. Our double-decker train towers beside us.

We've sprung for the sleeper car - not the most deluxe accomodations, but a tiny compartment, maybe 5' by 8'. This space can be made into two large facing seats (with optional tray table) or into two beds, one over the other. There is an impressively tiny closet (two hangers included), some bottled water, an electrical outlet, and a glorious picture window where we can watch America glide by.

We get a special treat - we're in the very last compartment on the train, so we also get the rear window view. This also puts us far from the whistle, which is probably good, because in the midwest there are quite a lot of crossings.

I am embarrassing us both by taking a gazillion pictures.

The sleeper car also includes all of our meals in the dining car. In fact, the sleeper counts as 'First Class', somewhat to my surprise, and later, amusement.  You make reservations for meals, because there's only about a dozen tables. And, as a party of two, we always are partnered with another party of one or two. This turns out to be one of my favorite aspects of the trip, because we get to have extended conversations with people from all walks of life, from all over America. We talk to a man who has made a short trip to run his grandson home to Chicago from Iowa, and we talk about water issues and farming and land prices. He's clearly a regular: the dining car attendant knows him by name. We meet a couple with a farm in Nebraska, tourists from England, a lovely elderly woman from Chicago travelling to visit her son in the Bay Area. We're all having a good time.

Although the midwest part is supposed to be "boring", I feel like a kid in a candy store (maybe it's all the corn-syrup-to-be), snapping pictures, my face pressed to the windows. I haven't been to this part of the midwest in any appreciable way, and everything is new to me. I drink in the green fields, the rivers, the towns, and try to record the memory they create with my camera.  Any question that Illinois is a corn state? No. Corn, and soy. Sometimes you see a stray corn plant trying to pop up among the soy. Near Chicago the farms are flat, but as we pass Princeton, the fields are pleasantly rolly. It's beautiful country.

Mmmm.... corn syrup

We cross the Mississippi River. It's maybe less dramatic than I expect (we're still in its northern section, after all), but there's still a fine bridge and an enormous rail yard on the Iowa side, in Burlington. I snap a picture of a rail car full of corn syrup for fellow Kossack OrangeClouds115. I know she'll appreciate it.

We stop in Ottumwa, Iowa - the home of MASH's fictional Radar O'Reilly - for a smoking break. There's no smoking on the train, so there's a list of towns  where the train stops for 15-20 minutes and passengers are allowed to disembark and mill about on the platform. I don't smoke, so I stretch my legs, take in the weather, and try to get pictures of our train. It's hard - too big and too close. I don't want to stray too far, stuck in an unfamiliar town with only my camera for company.

I fell asleep that night in Omaha, Nebraska.

I wake up at dawn the next morning, eager to see what's outside our window today. We're in Colorado, middle of nowhere, just our tracks and an occasional string of rail cars to keep us company. This is the flat, dry side of Colorado, where the plains are long and empty, covered with scrub.

We arrive in Denver. The train has to back in, and so a conductor comes and opens the rear door to our car so he can act as a spotter for the engineer. He is good-natured about the line of polite but eager tourists behind him, peering around him to take in the view. We take turns snapping pictures and everyone is having a good time. We're kind of sorry when we arrive and he has to close the door again.

This is easily the best station aside from Chicago. The station is near the stadium and several other big destinations. The signs are new and this is clearly a thriving place. We pull in next to a Ski Train, which in the winter takes skiiers straight to the resort. As part of servicing the train, men with absurdly long squeegees wash every window. I appreciate that.

At Denver, we start our detour. Instead of proceding west, through the heart of the Rockies, we skirt them to the north, through Wyoming. It's an easier, faster route (which is why it was the first one built, the Transcontinental Railroad route), and we'll arrive in Salt Lake City well ahead of schedule. I am happy and sad. I am excited about riding an unusual route that we'd otherwise never see, but I'm sad we won't go through the Rockies as planned. Oh well - we'll just have to come back and do the Zephyr again!

Wyoming curve Wyoming snow fence Wyoming red rocks

I enjoy watching a small river that is next to the tracks in Wyoming. It's carved a 10 foot bed for itself, and you can see the geology develop: it bends around to make an easier course, then ends up in a horseshoe shape, and as the channel gets deeper it finally breaks through the horseshoe and goes straight again. The marks of the previous bed are still apparent. Science is everywhere.

Devil's SlideThere is one remarkable rock formation as we travel across the north section of Utah, before rejoining the regular route in Salt Lake: the Devil's Slide. These parallel pinnacles of rock make a path from the top of the mountain to the bottom, right next to the tracks. The conductor announces this well in advance, and everyone is buzzing around the train looking for the best view. It's like a party. I exchange email addresses with a fellow passenger so I can send her the picture I took.

Dinner is in Salt Lake City. We're there for a couple of hours; one couple elects to get off and have dinner in the city. We are just a little too nervous about leaving all our worldly possessions on the train while it leaves our sight, so we stick with the dining car. The food isn't amazing, but it's better than I expected. The menu doesn't change but there are enough different choices that it works out OK.

We chug out of Salt Lake City, from the highly populated section near the dramatic mountain side, where you can get to snow and skiing in just 30 minutes, to the east side of the lake, where there is no vegetation and no population. Water is like that. In the midwest, water, and towns, are everywhere, at regular intervals. In the west, towns follow the water, and there won't be any more appreciable water along our journey until we get to Reno, on the far west side of Nevada.

Sleeeeeeepppp.

Winnemucca StationWinnemucca, Nevada, is our next smoke break stop. We're also changing to a fresh crew. It seems an odd place to station people: why not Salt Lake or Reno, where there is actual population? We can get off here, but the conductor announces that the platform is short here, and so everyone needs to disembark through the coach cars at the front of the train.

When I get off, I laugh.

By "platform" they mean "patch of asphalt." And by "station" they mean "bench with a rain cover next to a dumpster."  While I walk around outside, I see the crew toss trash bags into the dumpster. Definitely the least impressive station on the trip - but, in its own way, perhaps the most memorable.

Truckee RiverWe reach the Truckee River, and now we're in familiar territory. I have been in the Sierras many times, and here, east of Reno, we parallel I-80 as well as the Truckee. I'm used to seeing the tracks from the road, not the road from the tracks. We climb the hill to Donner Summit, and go through the remarkable snowshed tunnels. This is amazing territory. I always marvel that people came through this route with wagons and oxen. Even today, with a superhighway making the path obvious and smooth, that would be a serious feat. The boulders and rough country to either side of the road used to be right in the way. The first travellers used winches to traverse this path. The hard labor of thousands of people, working with pickaxes and dynamite and shovels, still eases my way today. Thanks.

Once we pass Donner Summit, it's not long until we're back in urban California, which is extending its mighty tentacles into formerly remote and rural towns like Truckee and Auburn. And as we sit on the tracks on the north Bay, near Suisun, waiting for the drawbridge to close that will admit us to Martinez, I'm happy and sad. It's been a great trip, and I'm sorry it's over. But I'm happy, because train travel isn't as dead as I thought. Indeed, the station at Martinez is bustling with commuter trains connecting Sacramento and the Bay Area. Even in California, we are starting to have trains again.

We returned home from our trip relaxed and relatively ready to return to our lives after two days of quiet leisure, reading, writing, and generally having no obligations. In contrast, had we flown back on Sunday, we would've travelled all night to get home and been trying to work on Monday, exhausted and cranky. The train was the way to go home, for sure.

I will have to use them more often.

Tags: Amtrak, trains, mass transit, travel (all tags)

Permalink | 17 comments

  • I originally wrote most of this (0 / 0)

    on the train, but it's taken me forever to find the time to sort through the pictures and choose just a few. When I said I took a lot, I wasn't kidding: there are approximately 1,200 pictures from this 2 1/2 day trip. And, there would have been more if I hadn't run low on battery in the Sierras. Viva la digital camera!

    A great inexpensive excursion for kids is to get on whatever commuter railroad system is near you, and just  go out and back. Cheap, fun, and exciting.

  • We love trains! (0 / 0)

    DH is able to ride the train to work and bikes to the station. I'm always so jealous as he gets to read the paper and chat with fellow commuters on the way. I also get a little green when he calls on his way home to let me know that he is enjoying a beer in the dining car. On the other hand he has to get online every morning to check if the train is running on time, since it's not a guarantee. Most of the time it is, but still. And the real bummer is on the few occasions when his train gets stuck behind a freight train on the way home. Nevertheless, we love train travel and would love to see more priority given to Amtrak and rail improvement for commuters and travelers.

    Your pictures are stunning and your trip sounds like so much fun - I would love to go cross country by train!

  • I have no idea why (0 / 0)

    "we the only industrialized country without a solid passenger rail system again?"

    The few times I have been able to travel by train I have loved it.
    Way better then air travel (which I hate) and avoid at all costs.
    It really is a much more civilized way to travel.

    • I forgot (0 / 0)

      I forgot to mention that because of our location (little rock, ar) you end up going to St. Louis or Chicago and then maybe Indianpolis before going to your true destination which makes a 12 hour trip by car (that would be going to Louisville to visit family) almost a 24 hour trip.
      Not bad if you have the time.
      The other destination would be Springfield, Mo. and there is not even a stop there.

      So even though I drive rather then fly I would rather go by train...we just live in the wrong spot to use it affectivly.

      I wish we would fund train travel fully and all those little stations all over the country were still open.

      • One of the people I talked to on the train (0 / 0)

        lives a quarter mile from the tracks - but in a town halfway between two stations an hour apart. He was talking about how he would love to use the train to actually get to those places.

        Where we live now, we are not well served by airports, and so the train plus bus combination (which is how Amtrak serves our town) is in some instances very competitive. If I could have internet access the whole way, that would be a huge advantage.

        I also chatted for a while from a lady from... North Dakota, I think. She told me they can't fly anywhere for less than $900 or so, and so they do nearly all their travel by train.

        The network is very thin, and you're right that there are many trips where rail is not practical with the current routes.

  • We were just talking last night (0 / 0)

    about how cool the sound of a train in the distance is.  I live about 5 miles from the nearest tracks and have the pleasure of the horn lulling me to sleep at night.  Dreamy...

    "What you once were isn't what you want to be anymore..."

    by folkgirl on Sun Jan 27, 2008 at 02:33:07 PM PDT

  • What a great and wonderful post! (0 / 0)

    I completely agree with you.  When I was 8 back in 1961, my Mom, brother and me took the train from Helena, MT to Orlando, FL to see my grandparents.  The trip remains one of the highlights of my life. My brother and I loved the domed view cars.  We spent the night in a hotel in Chicago--we had never seen a big city before.

    I just wish I could take the train or my kids could take the train now from Seattle to Montana but beyond Spokane, it goes along the highline in Montana---hours from any major city like Missoula, Butte, or Helena.  It is just stupid.

  • James Kunstler (0 / 0)

       Have you heard of James Howard Kunstler? He wrote The Long Emergency, which I want to read. I like reading his website. The Eyesore of the Month is really funny. In his Jan. 14, 2008 Clusterfuck Nation Chronicle he talks about rebuilding our railroads, along with a bunch of other commonsense ideas for preparing for peak oil, environmental problems, economic problems, etc.:

    Here's what we better start doing.
        Stop all highway-building altogether. Instead, direct public money into repairing railroad rights-of-way. Put together public-private partnerships for running passenger rail between American cities and towns in between. If Amtrak is unacceptable, get rid of it and set up a new management system. At the same time, begin planning comprehensive regional light-rail and streetcar operations.
        End subsidies to agribusiness and instead direct dollar support to small-scale farmers, using the existing regional networks of organic farming associations to target the aid. (This includes ending subsidies for the ethanol program.)
        Begin planning and construction of waterfront and harbor facilities for commerce: piers, warehouses, ship-and-boatyards, and accommodations for sailors. This is especially important along the Ohio-Mississippi system and the Great Lakes.
        In cities and towns, change regulations that mandate the accommodation of cars. Direct all new development to the finest grain, scaled to walkability. This essentially means making the individual building lot the basic increment of redevelopment, not multi-acre "projects." Get rid of any parking requirements for property development. Institute "locational taxation" based on proximity to the center of town and not on the size, character, or putative value of the building itself. Put in effect a ban on buildings in excess of seven stories. Begin planning for district or neighborhood heating installations and solar, wind, and hydro-electric generation wherever possible on a small-scale network basis.

    There are many more ideas before and after this quote. All this may or may not interest you, but thinking about trains always makes me think of Kunstler these days.

  • How I wish I had time! (0 / 0)

    To have the time to ride the entire United States by train.  But in today's world, there is never time.  (We always fly everywhere.)  Well, maybe in retirement....

    I sometimes ride Amtrak from Sacramento to San Francisco, which is a lot better than driving.  (To me, at least.)  You just get on, look out the window, talk, read ... whatever.  You never have to worry about traffic from 49er or Giants games messing up your time.

    I LOVE IT!

  • Love trains too (0 / 0)

    What an awesome diary, Shenanigans!  I believe our country has an unhealthy obsession with cars with our dependence on foreign oil.  Add that to the fact that our country is a lot larger than most countries in Europe... and that's probably part of the reason why we don't have a solid passenger rail system.  

    20+ years ago, my brother and I took a train from London to Edinburgh.  It was great... we got to sleep, read, walk around.  And the scenery wasn't bad either!

    One of my favorite things about going to the Chicago is the ease of moving about the city via rail.  We often stay in the suburbs with family and take the train in to the city.  We took a train up to the north side to see a Cubs game at Wrigley.  I wish we had that here in Columbus.  It was proposed at one point in the past 8 years, but shot down by voters.  I don't get it... why wouldn't you want reliable public transportation in your town?  

  • NJ to Florida (0 / 0)

    My husband and I went roundrip to Florida from NJ, a 19 hour trip this past Oct. on Amtrak. It was the worst exp. of our lives.  It was overnite, but sleep was impossible.  The bathrooms were dirty.  The people on board, well, ugh.  Never again.  I'd imagine travel out west on trains is probably better, especially the scenery.  

    • Must be that line. (0 / 0)

      We went DC to Williamsburg, VA and then Williamsburg to Raleigh, NC, and our experience was hell, too. Yes, it was the people. But also the quality of the ride, the cleanliness, everything about it was unacceptable. Never going to take that trip again. I kept thinking I couldn't believe how much I missed the British rail system.

      "You're never more alone than when you're alone in a crowd."

      by Expat Briton on Tue Jan 29, 2008 at 02:41:47 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  • I crossposted this over to DK this morning (0 / 0)

    At DH's suggestion - and wow, it went to the top of the Recommended list. I guess people were happy to have something to talk about besides the primary!

  • Thank you so much for this diary! (0 / 0)

    I lived with a railfan for 16 years and we criss-crossed the country - regular service as well as "rare mileage". But we never made a great photo essay like yours - really conveys the spirit!

    In addition to fixing the rail infrastructure, etc., a minor improvement would be to pass a law that all interesting factories that face the train lines have a sign facing the tracks that says the company name, what product is being made in there, and what town it's located in. HOW many times have I awakened in the night and looked at some interesting steaming towers and wondered all three of those things. (Of course I would check the timetable but due to what you've written about the freight having priority, that's often unreliable.)

    In inhabited areas, the train often cuts through a long series of back yards. I would see carefully tended rosebushes in dry cracked ground and hanging laundry and some kids' toys and - whoosh - on to the next! It was like spying on another family's life but in little packets without ever getting the full story. After even half an hour of this I would get into a very strange mental state. The nice conversations at meals were a welcome relief...

Permalink | 17 comments