Mother Talkers

Namer's remorse

Tue Jan 01, 2008 at 09:39:46 AM PDT

I was looking around at different news articles this morning while the kids watched the Rose parade, and I found this little gem on CNN.com.

http://www.cnn.com/...

It's about parents who have a change of heart after naming their children. Days, weeks, months, even years later, they wish they had named their kids something different and seek to change the child's name.

This is something I had never thought of. We decided on names several months before our twins were born and I have never wished to change them. They are not unusual names, not super trendy names, they have meaning within our family, and those were all things we were looking for. But these folks did have a change of heart.

In one case, the parents had not picked a name before birth and felt rushed into completing the birth certificate so they could leave the hospital. They came to wish they had chosen a different name. In another case, as the child got older, the parents realized how many other girls had the same name and they wished their child had a more distinct name. In that case, they asked their daughter before changing her name [I believe she was four at the time].

So, I was wondering, is this common or just another one of those "trend" stories that is really a few isolated parents doing something? Any fellow MTers had naming remorse?

Tags: names, parenting, trends (all tags)

Permalink | 99 comments

  • no remorse here (0 / 0)

    I decided on my firstborn daughter's name about 7 years before she came along...and weirdly enough, it still felt right. She was Maya in my dreams and Maya in my belly and when she finally came out, she was just Maya. It fit.

    However, I am full of ambivalence about our (still hypothetical) 2nd child's name. I waver constantly. I can see how this might happen to a parent. I still have namers remorse about changing my married name. I wish I had made my maiden name my middle name. Someday maybe I will even get around to doing it. :-)

    The only namers remorse case that comes to mind is Meg Ryan:

    In January 2006, Meg adopted a Chinese baby girl named Daisy True.
    "I already had to change her name. I thought she was Charlotte and she’s just not... she’s a Daisy." --Meg Ryan on her adopted daughter’s name.

  • hmmm. Your post does (0 / 0)

    remind me of some feelings I've had.  We named our daughter after both our Moms.  My Mom's name was Marguerite (she died in 1997) and my DH's Mom's name is Ruth.  We put those two together for our daughter and while I love those names, I know that having Marguerite as a first name can be tricky.  People mispronounce and misspell it and it is lengthy to write.  

    My dd goes by the nickname Meg which can be confusing with security issues regarding names matching exactly when traveling these days. In school it can also be a pain. Often people assume her name is Megan.  And while it seems easy to correct a person who has called you by an incorrect name, it can be kind of awkward.

    Some of her IDs have her nickname and some have her "formal" name.  If there weren't security issues, I would tend to use her nickname for any flight bookings, but I never do now since her driver's license reflects her formal name.

    So, while I do love her given names, I know they cause some inconvenience and sometimes I catch myself thinking it would have been easier to name her something different.  sigh.

    With my ds I have no regrets.  I've always loved his name - even before he was born.  I've only known one other man with the same name as his, but I notice it has become more common.  His name is Mason.  When he was going through his younger years, I'm not sure he was tremendously fond of his name, but I think he really enjoys it now as it is a strong name and uncommon.

    • love it (0 / 0)

      She will love Marguerite when she is older, if she doesn't already.  Meg is cute too and a good, easy name.

      • thanks.... (0 / 0)

        I have memories of hearing my Dad calling my Mom by Marguerite rather than her nickname Maggie and feeling like it was so special and a bit mysterious sounding to me.  He would also call her Meg which no one else did.  She was always Maggie throughout her personal life and career as well.  So I have very fond memories of that name and hope that my dd does come to love it as well.  I've told her that if she really felt strongly against it, I would be ok with changing it.  It is her name afterall.

      • I agree (0 / 0)

        A woman named Marguerite will instantly seem mysterious and elegant, and who wouldn't want to be friends with a Meg?
        • :>) what a sweet comment. (0 / 0)

          I do love the name Meg -- I guess it was hearing my Dad all those years ago -- it seemed so intimate and special when he would say her name either as Marguerite or Meg.  Now when I say my daughter's it is an almost gut-level knowing that my Mom is close by.

    • My DH is Mason (0 / 0)

      and we've met very few other Masons.  His came from his mother's maiden name.   His problems come because his last name is a common man's first name - since Mason can be a common last name, people always assume his name is backwards.  Other than that I think he likes his name - not too common, but not too obscure either.

    • Interesting (0 / 0)

      ... that you say many can't pronounce "Marguerite" correctly.  One of my college roommates had that as her middle name.  She always said we couldn't pronounce it correctly.  Try as I did to copy the way she said it, it was still wrong!  (Maybe it was because she was from NYC and I was an Okie, with that accent -- at the time.)

  • Sometimes I wish (0 / 0)

    I'd given my second daughter a different first name. I let DH come up with a short list of names he liked, and then he and I chose her name from that compilation. I gave him more say because I had pretty much dictated the choice of our first daughter's name.

    It's not that I dislike my second DD's name -- it's just that there are so many beautiful girl's names out there, and I wish I had chosen one that I was truly in love with (like my first daughter's name). However, her name seems to suit her and it has some cute nickname possibilities, so it's hers for good now.

  • An acquaintance of mine got divorced (0 / 0)

    last summer, and re-named her daughter (her only child). The girl now has a hyphenated last name. Before the divorce, she went by just her father's last name. Now her mom's maiden name is between her original first and last names. The mom kept her maiden name, and I guess she wanted her daughter to be identifiably hers. I can understand why she did this, but I have to think it must be incredibly awkward for the girl, who's already dealing with so much change ... not just her parents splitting up, but now a new name as well.

    • Eek (0 / 0)

      As a child of divorced parents, that is not a good idea IMO.  Ugh.  

      It's not such a big deal for a mom to have a different name that their kids these days, for many reasons, and divorce isn't the only one.

  • nicknames (0 / 0)

    My first name has a million nicknames and it has been such a PITA my whole life.  I've been called every version of it at different points of my life and now I insist on using the full version of it with anyone new I meet.  But I still have people calling me all sorts of names depending on when in my life I met them.

    I vowed that my children would have simple names that wouldn't be easily nicknamed and I think we succeeded on that.

    We had one boy name and one girl name in our minds for a long time before we got married, and now we've used them up.  If we had a third, I would be in trouble trying to come with another one!

  • Years and years later, (0 / 0)

    I'm still happy with the names we chose for our children.  

    While I've never known any parent to legally change their children's names, I do know that a couple of generations ago, it was very common to name a child one thing yet call him/her something totally different.  Sometimes the names they were called would be a shortened version of a middle name, and sometimes, it would be just totally random.  I suppose those were parents who decided, for whatever reason, that they didn't care for the name they had chosen for their child at birth.

    I did know one young man who would be in his 30s now who changed his name legally upon becoming an adult...his given name was "Hunter"...I can imagine that his father, my literature teacher in junior high school, named him after Hunter Thompson.  Now, this wasn't a name that was used 35 years ago in the moderately conservative town that I grew up in...and he did, I imagine, encounter a lot of stares and "huhs" growing up, so upon turning 18, he legally changed his name to "John"...the most commonplace male name used in the English speaking world.

  • Name changing (0 / 0)

    One of my best friends changed her second son's name about a week after he was born. She decided she didn't love the name she gave him and her DH just loved another name, so she called the hospital, and it turned out the lady who files the SS paperwork had been out all week and had not sent it in.  It was a sign.

    I know a couple of other people who also aren't crazy about the names they gave their kids.  But I don't think they would consider changing them after months or years.  

    I like both our boys' names.  For the second one, I came up with a list, DH crossed off what he didn't like, then we picked one when we were at the hospital.  Actually, he picked it because my wild hormones were making me crazy trying to decide.  But I knew that since it had been on my list, I would like whichever he chose.

  • I like my kids' names. (0 / 0)

    I think there is a certain suitability to names though and I'm always slightly weirded out when people name the baby before meeting them.   We had a short list and walked around the room calling the baby the name to see which one stuck.  After we had more than one child I practised saying them together to see if I'd feel stupid calling them all in for dinner.  

    I do find it odd how all of the names that were on the short list for my daughter are the names of girls in her class.   We didn't know anyone named those names at the time but apparently everyone who was having a girl in 1998 was thinking the same things.  

    "As God is my witness, I thought turkeys could fly"

    by lonestar canuck on Tue Jan 01, 2008 at 12:36:38 PM PDT

  • Middle names (0 / 0)

    My DH felt very strongly that our kids have his parents first names as middle names.  When my DD was born, I felt strongly about her first name (Leah), so I compromised on the middle name (Jeanne, from my MIL).  When my DS was born, eight years later, it made sense to use my DH's father's name (he died 30 years ago) as his middle name.

    I'm not wild about these middle names.  I don't particularly like my MIL, and I think my DD doesn't like sharing her name.  DS's middle name is an unusual name, and I have no emotional connection to it, since I never knew my FIL.

    Ah well...I love their first names... both are slightly unusual, but easy to say, spell, and remember.

  • While I'm sharing (0 / 0)

    about names...my cousin married a man who is the "third".  His father and grandfather have the same name and so when she had a baby boy the name was already chosen for him.   I find this kind of odd.   I can see a middle name as a tribute but a first name to me ought to be for that individual and not just part of some giant generational chain.  

    Am I just weird and disrespectful of tradition?  Discuss.  

    "As God is my witness, I thought turkeys could fly"

    by lonestar canuck on Tue Jan 01, 2008 at 12:42:01 PM PDT

    • not for me (0 / 0)

      I like using part of someone else's name [our DS's middle name is the same as DH's; and DD is named after one of my grandmothers and one of DH's grandmothers] but taking the whole name and making it a Jr. or III is not for me.

      I think part of the issue may be for me that I've known some boys with that type of name who ended up with a version of the name that sounded too childish [eg, Bill and Billy or Tommy and Little Tommy] to work when they grew up, but there needed to be some way to distinguish when they were both together.

      • I have to confess, (0 / 0)

        we have a bit of a problem with this.  We haven't done "jr's" or "seconds" in our family, but we have become stuck on the name "James".  My father is "James" and has always been called just "James".  My brother is "James" as well, but called "Jim".  My son is "James" and has always been "Jamie", while my brother's son is "James" and called "Jay".  We have to get off the kick now, because I'm not sure how many versions of the name are left.  

        For awhile, my son did want to be called "James"...however, in the past few years he's gone back to wanting to be "Jamie".  Not sure why, other than the fact that in school there were also a lot of other "James'".

        • We're stuck on Joseph (0 / 0)

          My grandpa and uncle on my mother's side are Joseph's.  My great grandfather by way of my maternal grandfather was a Joseph.  My brother and my male cousin on my mom's side have it as a middle name.  I named my first doll "Baby Joey" so naturally when I had a son he had to be a Joseph.  I know it's overdone even in my family but it is my favorite boy name and always has been.  There's enough suitable nicknames with it that we know who is who too.

    • My dad was named for his grandfather (0 / 0)

      as were all the first sons in his family, meaning that he had two cousins with the same first name (one of those cousins shared the last name as well).  Since they all lived close, he said it was kind of a pain.  When my brother was born, I noticed that he didn't keep the tradition as there was already one grandchild named for our grandfather.  

  • no namer's remorse here! (0 / 0)

    We had a couple of names and combinations worked out, for both boys and girls, but left the final say until Jessica was actually born. Her middle name, Louise, is from a cousin of mine who lives in Paris and was so kind and like an auntie when we lived in Europe. We also had Sarah Irene picked out - Irene is my middle name and my dad's mother's name. I love the name Irene, and would love to name a daughter that as a first name, but said in an Australian accent, it's absolutely atrocious.

    FWIW, Jessica and Sarah were DH's choices. Personally, I preferred Sarah, but Jessica is definitely a Jessica.

    • They're both lovely (0 / 0)

      I like the combination with Sarah Irene in particular.  Maybe if you have another girl...

      We're in the odd position with this one where we have a lot of girl's names we really like and very few boy's names.  I'm not absolutely in love with our choice of a boy's name and we're still undecided on the middle name but we've narrowed it down to two choices.  We really need to have 2 girls for all of the names we love but I don't see that happening.  Boy or girl, I'm pretty sure this is it.

      • so funny (0 / 0)

        Actually, we're saving Sarah Irene as a girl's choice.

        Just like you, we had a few girls' combinations, but only one boy combination - Jacob James. DH's middle name is James, after his maternal grandfather, and my mother's maiden name is Jacobsen. I've always loved the name Jacob and the nickname Jake (my maternal grandfather's nickname was Jake and he was a commodore in the Navy, and apparently a dashingly handsome man!). Of course, if we have a boy that means we have two "J" kids, but who cares?

        • I love the name Jake (0 / 0)

          A friend of mine has three girls - all J names...Her husband had all H names in his family of origin with 5 kids...Hunter, Hank, Hayden, Henry, and oops, can't remember the fifth.

          My kids are both M names...and our last name is M.

          You're right Rachel, who cares?...

        • That's the trouble with "J" names (0 / 0)

          Once you start, it's hard to stop.  We have a Joseph and a Joshua so far.  We'll go with John for this one if it's another boy so he won't feel like the odd man out.  The funny thing is my first cousin on my mom's side has three boys and they are Jacob, Jesse, and Joel.  It's very interesting when the kids are all together.  There's a lot of "J, J, You!!!  Stop that!"  Oh well, those are the names we loved.

        • Eli (0 / 0)

          was almost a Jacob.  Then we saw it had become very common here in the states.  So then we thought about Jackson, because we love Jackson Pollack.  We probably would have called him Jack, but there were a lot of Jacks around us here, so again, we chucked the name.

          Elias as a name choice came from my friend Lane's list of names from her pregnancy with her first child.  One day during my pregnancy, we were over at her house and she pulled out the sheet from her dayplanner from 1999 that she had scribbled name ideas on.  Somehow Elias just seemed right.  Not Elijah, but Elias.  Even though it's the Greek version and not the Jewish one, I preferred it.  His Hebrew first name is Eliyahu, which is Elijah.

          But he's really Eli.

          Oh, and no regrets on our choices, we love them both.

        • two "S" kids (0 / 0)

          my kids' names both start with "S" as does mine, obviously. we don't really notice it actually. i was more concerned when we had named our first son Sage and were thinking about naming a girl, if we had one, "Olive." we both love the name Olive, but i didn't like the idea that our kids would both have names that were colors and food.

  • I've always loved the name Devon... (0 / 0)

    I wanted to call my second child Devon.  Dave didn't like it so we went with something else.  Same story for children 3 and 4, so I gave up on the name.  By the time I had my boy-girl twins, I deferred to Dave (mostly) for names.  He chose Ryan and Devon.  And she's such a Devon!  Maybe he knew something I didn't.

    Let your life be a counter-friction to stop the machine. Henry David Thoreau

    by half dozen on Tue Jan 01, 2008 at 02:31:55 PM PDT

  • I had some. . . (0 / 0)

    for a while with DD #1, who was born in '93.  Shortly after, we started hearing her name everywhere.  It was apparently very overused in some sets,but because we were the first of our friends to have a baby, we weren't terribly tuned in.  We panicked for a while, but there has been very little duplication in her school career.  It suits her, I think.  With DD#2, I wish we had spelled hers another way - her name starts with a G, and I cringe when someone uses the soft instead of hard sound.  Hers is fairly unique, anyway - there's never been another in her class.

    • hard and soft "G" (0 / 0)

      I also really love the name Genevieve, and am particularly fond of the way the French pronounce it, with the soft G and the vowel pronunciations (kinda comes out sounding like "Ghzohn-vi-yeve". So elegant!). But I just know that we'd be asking for trouble if we did do the French version of Genvieve. The poor kid would be constantly correcting people and I'm sure she'd get made fun of for having a pretentious name!

  • Remorse for both (0 / 0)

    For my younger son I wanted Nicolas, but DH didn't think it worked with his last name.  Too bad, because this kid is definitely a Nicky.  My older son's name doesn't suit him at all - as it turns out, the name his birthmom chose was a much better fit and I now use it as a nickname.

  • Namebivalence (0 / 0)

    My older son's middle name is my grandfather's name, Deane, and after he was born and named both my mother and husband have expressed regret that we didn't drop the "e" at the end of his name.

    I like having it match my grandfather, but it's true you don't need the E and he will have to spell it for people if they are ever writing it down.  But how often do you really have to tell people your middle name anyway?

  • No remorse (0 / 0)

    I'm not fond of Simone's middle name, Vivian, but I never really liked it and agreed to it anyway.  I like the story of it, so no regrets.

    I do know some people who have been oddly indecisive about names, though.  My grandparents disagreed on my aunt's name and eached called her by their preferance into her adulthood.  

    One mother I know got very into numerology when her daughter was in her late teens and tried to get the daughter to change her name or the spelling of it.   Daughter didn't go for it.

    • more name stories (0 / 0)

      two -- one a guy I dated, whose first and middle names were from someone on each side of his family. His dad's side called him by the name from their side of the family; his mom's relatives called him by the name from their side of the family. He decided his name for school when he looked at which was easier to spell.

      My best friend's dad changed his first name when he became an adult. The reason this strikes me as odd is that he has always been called his middle name, both before and after he changed his first name. Seems unusual to go to the trouble to change a name that you don't even use.

  • I know people who have changed (0 / 0)

    I met a mom when our babies were newborns, and they changed the name when the kid was several months old (and after I stopped seeing them regularly, so I still think of the kid by his old name).

    Our first son's name fits him perfectly and I'm thrilled with the choice.  My husband only liked two names for the second kid, and I really disliked one, so we went with the second.  Honestly, I'm still not totally crazy about the name, and I don't think it fits him.  I guess it fits his personality well enough, but before he was born I assumed he would have dark hair (since everyone in our family does), yet somehow he ended up blonde and blue-eyed, and I think that's part of the reason the name doesn't seem to fit.

  • name remorse on my own name (0 / 0)

    Okay, I like it now, that I am 55, but I was named for my mother(who is still alive) and my brother was named for my dad. My brother(a ---III) kept the tradition, naming one son ---IV,and the one daughter with the wife's name. I had to live with a nickname all my life, so did my brother.(Imagine a CEO named "Rip",okay?)and in the family, I am called "Sis" but as an adult I use the full name(Katherine). I just feel like there was too much done to make the kids be just like the parents, which never happened.
    My son had a Chinese name when we adopted him, and we liked it and kept it. I know one girl adopted and given a nice name, but as a toddler she insisted on being called by the Chinese name, and her parents agreed(it was her middle name). It fits her so well, I have to think hard to recall the English name!

  • Back in the day (0 / 0)

    My grandmother has a very unusual name and always hated it.  But her mother and my grandfather both loved it, so when she was still out from giving birth, my grandfather named my mom the same thing as my grandmother.  Sure enough, my mom always hated it.  She was adamant that I would not share the burden.  Everyone thinks it is totally cool, but it is really more cool for an adult than a kid.  I would have been very self-conscious.

  • Nathaniel (0 / 0)

    My one year old is named Nathaniel. We weren't sure about it, and we have wavered. But now it fits. It means "God's gift". And that describes him perfectly.

  • funnily enough (0 / 0)

    Melbourne's broadsheet daily The Age just put out the article of the top 10 most popular names for boys and girls in Victoria in 2007. Number one name Boy - Jack; girl - Olivia. There are some really pretty names on the list...

    • The name Jack is a good one (0 / 0)

      I like Olivia as well.  I've always loved the name Grace and Molly --- but only had one girl to name.  I was surprised to see Chloe on the list - I don't hear that name that much.

      Here are a few that I find interesting:  Owen, Bryce, Riley, Tatum, Hank and Henry.  Some of those are unisex.  My daughter swears she'll be naming her daughter, should she be lucky enough to have one, Tatum.  And she loves the name Riley.  Names are a lot of fun to banter about.

  • No remorse (0 / 0)

    despite the spur-of-the-moment naming.  DH looked up names on the internet and put two together, just in time for CPS to steal the kid.

  • Name changing (0 / 0)

    I've only known one person to change the name of her baby months after its birth-- many years ago, a friend of our family's changed the name of her newborn from Marie to Diana when the child was several months old. It was only this year I realized that this coincided exactly with Princess Diana's wedding-- the mom was probably swept up in the excitment.

  • Searching for a girl's name (0 / 0)

    I love my DS's name.  Can't imagine him as anything else.

    For our currently gestating baby (due July 1st-ish) we have two boys names we can't decide between (Frank and Gus)  and can't seem to agree on a girl's name at all.  Everything I like, my partner doesn't.  Including "Lucy", my long standing girl name choice; it's also his sister's girl pick and she has told me she would have been furious if I had used it.

    But since I am adamant that this baby HAS to be a girl (haha! No one yell at me, I just want a girl, but know I will be happy with whatever I am blessed with), we better pick a girl's name soon.  Something not too common, that sounds sort of "old fashioned".  Any suggestions? (No S names)

    We laugh about last names and the confusion we will cause in school.  I am keeping my maiden name forever, DS has his father's name, which is different than my fiance's name (and he will be the one who is seen as DS's father in school settings, since his biological dad can't be bothered).  The baby will have the same name as my fiance.  We're thinking of getting one of those address signs for the house that says "House of Smith, Jones, Carter", just to see if they can make it fit!

    • Funny about the last names! (0 / 0)

      In my family, my son doesn't have my last name -- OR his dad's last name, so we laugh that all three of us have our own last names.

      My son's last name is my maiden name. His Dad has his own last name, obviously. And I go by my married last name (although I made my maiden name my middle name on my SS card when I got married).

      • i love Ruby... (0 / 0)

        but you know it would never have made my list when naming my dd.  however, through a twisted long story of pet names i concocted several years ago for my dd, ruby became a nick name that has stuck.  it bears absolutely no resemblance to my dd's actual formal name or diminutive that everyone calls her...yet both my dh and i call her ruby. i love the name.
    • Ruby? (0 / 0)

      Alice?
      Opal?
      Eleanor?
      Pearl?

    • So many girl suggestions (0 / 0)

      These were mostly names I loved that were rejected by DH.

      Anabel
      Delilah
      Fiona
      Julia
      Lux
      Ilsa

      The only ones dh liked were Julia and Ilsa, but that time we had a boy ;-)

      • love (0 / 0)

        Anabel and Delilah, those are lovely!

        I recently stumbled on the name Aliya. And me and DH fell in love with it! Problem is, my BIL and SIL, who we are very close to, just had a baby girl and named her Leah. I feel like the names sound too similar and don't want them to feel like we're "stealing" the name or some such.

        Ah, so many facets to consider...

        • As them (0 / 0)

          you might be surprised!  Aliya is so pretty.  I also like Ayana, for a similar name that doesn't sound much like Leah.  And Jane, like Sweet Jane, but that was another line in the sane.  "Referencing Sweet Jane is not going not going to help your case," Jeremy said, lol.

          Have at any of my girl names; we're almost certainly done.

          • thought about asking them (0 / 0)

            but they're so sweet, I'm afraid they would say, "Of course!" even if they really didn't like the idea. I don't want them to feel obligated or awkward, you know?

            We'll see...

            I'm also still stuck on Isabel, a name I have loved for years but recently discarded because Isabella is now so common. But the more I think about, the more I am leaning toward just using the damn name, because I like it!

            Of course, this could all be a moot point if we don't have another girl. :-)

            • My mom (0 / 0)

              had two younger cousins with the same name as her, and it bothered her, so you're probably right.

              Isabel is popular because it's beautiful.  I'm pretty sure Milo will  turn out to be insanely common, too, but we both loved it, so there you go.

          • I know an Ayanna (0 / 0)

            (with two "n"s). Do you know what it means in Swahili? It totally fits here, because she is a gorgeous woman with a real presence!

      • We really like Julia too (0 / 0)

        I've taught an Anibel and I think that is a beautiful name.  Julia seems to be a common name or at least it was a few years ago so it's our middle name choice at the moment.  We would like Mary Julia for a girl asMary is a solid, old-fashioned name that doesn't seem to be in favor so much these days.

        I really like Erika's selections too.  Among our friends who have had daughters in recent years there is a Ruby and an Eleanor.  Lily is a nice name too.  It's not too common and has an old fashioned sound to it.  I think that was on our short list for a while as was Rose.  They both seem like names that would grow up well with a child.

      • I love Delilah! (0 / 0)

        But we said everyone would think we were naming her after the Plain White T's song! lol

        Anabel was my favorite horse when I was a little girl, and our dog's name is Bella, which is close sounding (I always imagine what it would be like yelling the names!)

        I like Eleanor a lot, but he associates it with some car in a bad movie. [rolling my eyes]  Gretchen is a favorite, but a friend of ours is named Gretchen.  So yeah, there are way too many factors to consider.  I hate how you can love a name and then meet someone with that name, or read something, or whatever, and it sort of "ruins" that name for you.

        He said a lot of mine were "too Southern" sounding.  Included in that list is Ruby, Mae, Virginia...

        I said we could name her June...but only if she's born in July!  Haha, funny to consider that we could pick June for a girl and August (Gus) for a boy, both for a July baby!  Too kitschy?

      • I like (0 / 0)

        Delia (Delilah reminded me).

        Ilsa is a lovely name, too, but with our family last name (which you know, Erin!), it would just be awful!!! There are a couple of Norwegian names I just adore, but could never use for that reason - Agathe, for example.

    • options (0 / 0)

      we had several girls names that we liked when we were still wondering if we were having girls or boys or one of each.

      Julia
      Hannah
      Olivia
      Emma
      Lily

      and the one we went with, Grace [whose middle name is Virginia] Of course, many of those names have become more common in the past 11 years.

      I know you said no "S" names but I really like the name Sadie.

      someone else suggested Eleanor and I like it as well. I also like Elaine which is not very common these days.

    • I love Lucy. (0 / 0)

      If you want old-fashioned, what about Grace?  I also like Meryl or Mary..and of course I love the nickname Kate, so Katherine would work too.

      By the way I love Gus.  Too bad about Lucy.  That's a great pick.

      • Lucy was my favorite (0 / 0)

        Short for Lucinda.  I wanted to sing her "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" every day. :(  

        Katherine and Margaret (and their shortened versions as nicknames) are also on the short list.  I've always sort of wished I was a Katherine.  There's already a Grace and a Mary in the family, so those are out.

        I also like Cecilia and Calliope.

        • well now....I love (0 / 0)

          the short versions of Margaret.  My dd is Marguerite with nickname of Meg.  But there are lots of versions to pick from; Maggie, Molly, even Megan I suppose....Katherine is a wonderful name too with the nickname Kate which to me is just plain great.  I have a friend whose daughter's name is Zanique with nickname of Zanny - I've always thought that was an interesting name and quite beautiful and unique.

          You have lots of great choices --- Calliope could be tough in the early years, but I like Calli as the nickname a lot.

          My dd has had some issues with Marguerite esp when she was younger --- currently I think she has discovered the beauty of it although she always goes by Meg.

  • we changed the spelling (0 / 0)

    we ended up changing the spelling of our baby's name. originally we named him sasha. but because it's a name that is used for boys and girls, we realized that when people saw it written down, they thought he was a girl. so we changed it to "sascha" to try to make it look more masculine.

    i love both of the names we picked for our kids. i felt silly that we hadn't figured out the spelling we wanted from the beginning, but it wasn't hard to change it.

  • No regrets here (0 / 0)

    I love my son's name, Zachary. He was born in 1991, and at the time, I only knew one other Zachary ... and apparently, so did the millions of other mothers who chose that name. I still love it, though. He is such a Zach.

    I also love my baby daughter's name, Mia (not to be confused with Maya -- I hadn't even thought about people getting confused with that until we named her). For a short time, I was stuck on wanting the name "Ava," but my husband didn't like it. We both agreed early on in my pregnancy that we loved Mia, and it definitely fits her. I love the meaning, too -- "mine."

    I'm happy with their middle names, too, but I didn't pick them. I let Dad choose both times.

    • By the way (0 / 0)

      I should also add that I'm one of those babies that the Mom decided to change names on.

      I was born with an entirely different first name, and it's quite a strange one -- I was named after my paternal grandmother's nickname.

      When my parents got divorced when I was still a baby, my mom and my entire family started calling me by my middle name, Kay. It stuck, and when I was 6, she changed my entire name legally -- even changing my LAST name to her new husband's name (because I was adopted by him). I was in kindergarten then, learning to write my last name, and suddenly I had to try to remember a new one.

      So, I'm funny about changing names. I don't like it. It didn't scar me for life or anything like that, but it's just weird. And unnecessary. If they wanted to call me something else, they could have done that without changing it all on paper.

Permalink | 99 comments