Mother Talkers

He's Pretty in Pink

Sun Mar 25, 2007 at 06:15:57 PM PDT

I hate pink. I was a tomboy as a kid and made a point to reject all things girly, especially the color pink. When I was pregnant, my husband and I decided that we would find out the gender, but then not tell anyone. Our reasoning was that if we had a girl, we didn't want pink clothes. Our kid was going to be totally gender neutral until she or he was old enough to express opinions.  

We had a boy did manage to keep his wardrobe and toys pretty neutral. An occasional sports-themed shirt from my mother-in-law did make it into the clothing rotation, but practically all his clothes could have also been worn by a girl without anyone thinking twice. I was enormously disappointed when he became your typical truck-obsessed 2-year-old boy, and gave in to the onslaught of truck clothes. After all, I had said that our kids would be neutral until they expressed preferences, and he definitely had a preference. Besides, he had suddenly developed very strong opinions about his clothing and it was a little easier to start off the day if he could choose a truck shirt.

Soon, it even became a struggle to dress him in a truck shirt. He just hated wearing shirts. At the same time, I noticed an interesting trend starting. On our weekly trip to Trader Joe's, he asked for a pink balloon. Then he did it again next week. He started pointing out the color pink wherever he saw it. There was no denying that pink was his favorite color. I had a gift card to a clothing store and I was desperately looking for shirts he would be willing to wear when I saw it on the sale rack. It was pink, it was a girls' shirt, and I knew he would love it. My husband rolled his eyes when he saw my purchase and asked if I was really serious, but quickly changed his tune when he saw how happy our son was to be dressed in pink.

After the same pink shirt was worn for several days in a row, I faced a dilemma. I'm a very frugal, practical person, and my son already had a full wardrobe of clothes. However, I also try very hard to respect his personal preferences in certain arenas, and I decided I would make an effort to acquire more pink clothes. So after a trip to the Goodwill store and a few emails out to friends with older girls, we had enough clothes to keep him in pink all the time.

I'm still not sure if this is a short-term phase as it's only gone on for a couple weeks, but I must admit that I'm enjoying it.  It's been very interesting to see how people react. A surprising number don't even notice.  Someone who I've spoken to at the playground several times asked me if he was actually a girl. My mother is trying to be open-minded, but keeps sending me links to pink boys' shirts. My son really prefers the frilly, flowery pink clothes, and I'm not too into the preppy pink shirt look myself, so for now we're just going with what we can get cheap. I'm still not crazy about pink myself, but I actually think my son looks quite nice in the color. I found myself lingering by the pink Easter dresses on a recent trip to Costco, but my husband couldn't go that far yet.  

I realize this probably won't go on forever, but I'm wondering how and when it will change. Will he move past it on his own once his obsession has been sated? Will he just start seeing pink as another color to wear occasionally, and warm up to the other more traditionally boy colors in his wardrobe? My fear is that the impetus for change won't come from within, but will be because someone else is going to tell him that it's not OK for boys to wear pink. At least I know he won't get that message from me, and I hope one day he will look back at pictures of him in pink, and instead of feeling embarrassed, will realize his mom was trying to let him discover himself.

Tags: pink, gender-neutral (all tags)

Permalink | 31 comments

  • My son (0 / 0)

    loves pink, has me paint his finger nails and toes blue, dress up in fairy costumes, and is obsessed with Dora. He wears his sister's Dora hand me downs, including her Dora sneakers. So cute. I have no qualms about it. I say WHATEVER to anyone who worries about it. He'll be embarassed, no doubt, but I'm not worried about that, either. I'm embarassed looking at the 1980s attire I chose for myself as a young adult!!!

    Good for you for letting him think pink! It's just a stupid color, after all. Indeed, I believe prior to 1920, pink was the 'boy' color. Boy babies were wrapped in pink blankets, girls in white.

    • The NY Times article (0 / 0)

      about Princess culture mentioned that fact about pink being a boys' color in the past since it was seen as a softer form of red.  And blue was girly, which is why Snow White and earlier princesses were dressed in blue.  I've shared this with several people when discussing why my son is wearing pink, and I think it reinforces the idea that it really is just a color.  It's crazy how wrapped up we can get in certain colors being for certain genders, and how there's really no basis for it.  A Chinese colleague of my husband's was once shocked to see our son in red since that is a girl color in China.

    • pink for boys, blue for girls (0 / 0)

      is what I learned somewhere, prior to 1900 or 1920 or whatever. Pink was a more vibrant and alive color, and therefore given to the male of the species. And blue was more demure and soft, hence given to the females. I really need to google that.

      "the "well-informed citizenry" envisioned by our framers has degenerated into a "well-amused audience." Tad Daley, Alternet - interview w/ Al Gore 05/22/07

      by cgiselle12 on Wed Mar 28, 2007 at 10:26:25 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  • gotta agree (0 / 0)

    I say, let it go. Much better for him to explore what he likes than to feel stifled. It's a color and it sounds like you've managed to combine allowing your son to explore his style with keeping to practicals (ie, not buying a whole new wardrobe when they're growing so quickly!). Sounds fine to me.

    I don't think anyone would have a problem with a little girl who loved blue and wearing truck/sports-themed clothing; the same should be true in reverse for boys!

  • Sounds like you're handling it just right (0 / 0)

    And kudos to your DH, too, because alot of men would not be okay with their son wearing a pink girls' shirt!

    My son used to really enjoy walking around in my shoes [mostly mules] and it never mattered a bit to my DH [who had loved to wear his mom's hats when he was a young boy]. But I have known so many moms whose husbands completely freaked out if their son put on any of mom's accessories or high-heeled shoes. It seems nuts to me to react that way, but apparently it's much more common [at least where I live] than the reaction my husband has.

    • Yeah, my husband's been pretty great about this (0 / 0)

      I knew in theory he would support a boy wearing pink, but I wasn't sure if he'd actually be OK with it.  My husband even took our son shopping for pink pajamas yesterday so he could be in pink 24/7!

  • Pink is Peachy (0 / 0)

    I think you're right on with this.

    There is this awesome little boy in my daughter's preschool class who wears frilly dresses.  I hope neither of them ever feel like they have to change.

  • Baby boys used to wear dresses (0 / 0)

    Until about 75 years ago, it was pretty common for boys to wear dresses until they could walk.  Sounds practical to me...easier to change the diaper.  

    On another note, I was the first grandchild on my mother's side, and my grandma made a beautiful baptism gown that could have a pink ribbon for a girl & a blue ribbon for a boy.  I wore it, my brothers wore it, and a few of our cousins.  When my brother had his first child, a boy, he didn't want his boy in a "dress," so my nephew wore a little shorts outfit.  I thought it was so ridiculous; I can't believe how macho my brother thinks he is.  We had DS baptized while he was in the hospital, but when he came home, I dressed him in the gown just to take pictures.  For me, tradition trumps gender oppression!

  • Dr. Phil (0 / 0)

    There seems to be lots of guy's clothes in pink now or with pink undertones.

    I think he will move on to something else himself, based on his age (he's 2 right?).

    I saw an interesting Dr. Phil once that said this about letting boys wear girl's clothes, not sure if I agree:

    Robby's 5-year-old son loves to play with Barbies and prefers wearing girl's clothes. She asks Dr. Phil how to deal with this behavior, which she doesn't think is normal.

    "There are developmental stages in kids and it is not unusual, particularly for young boys, to experiment and get stuck on certain stimulus items," says Dr. Phil. Particularly because the little boy has two older sisters, he says, it's not unusual.

    "This is not a precursor to your son being gay," explains Dr. Phil. He'll know that in time, but this is not an indication of his sexual orientation.

    Dr. Phil tells Robby that she has a job to do: "Direct your son in an unconfusing way. Don't buy him Barbie dolls or girl's clothes. You don't want to do things that seem to support the confusion at this stage of the game ... Take the girl things away, and buy him boy toys."

    Most importantly, he tells Robby, "Support him in what he's doing, but not in the girl things."

    • What??? (0 / 0)

      I don't understand that piece of advice at all.  Take away the girl things and buy him boy toys because he's not supposed to like Barbies or girl's clothes?

      I think that is crazy.  Why wouldn't you support kids wanting to be who they are, just because boys aren't "supposed" to like dolls?

      • My daughter (0 / 0)

        wears plenty of boy clothes, has trucks and cars and building toys... That's OK with everyone.

        Oh, except one salesclerk, who was horrified that I bought my daughter Boys' socks. They're just plain white socks, and the boys'  had StainGuard.

    • Dr Phil (0 / 0)

      sheesh, what a moron. My brother has two older sisters - he played with 'girl' stuff and boy stuff - and so did we girls. My brother and my dad wear pink dress shirts all the time. Whatever. As in the color blue on girls issue, would Dr Phil advocate taking 'boy' toys from girls? So stupid. And, what's the deal with 'don't worry, he's not gay'? If he is, will it now be mom's 'fault' for not 'directing' him properly? Ugh ugh ugh. I know lots of gay guys who never played with dolls. The whole 'advice' on this reeks of heterosexist bull shit. Rant over. Sorry.

    • Yeah, that's pretty idiotic (0 / 0)

      The main reason I've been feeling like I should provide my son with pink clothes is that there's no good reason there wasn't any pink in his wardrobe before.  I wouldn't say I'm encouraging it or discouraging it.  I'm just trying to follow his lead in one of the few areas of his life I let him have control over.  I imagine I would do the same if he only wanted to wear orange.  He also has many "girl" toys that he enjoys, though he generally prefers trucks.  This morning he was playing with his navy blue doll stroller and told me he wished it were pink!  The bottom line is that I think we should just let our kids be who they are and provide them with lots of options to discover their own preferences, rather than dictating what they should and shouldn't like because of their gender.

      There's nothing I can do to change my son's sexual orientation.  He'll either be gay or he'll be straight.  But if he is gay, I like to think that the efforts I'm making while he's young will make him much more comfortable with himself, and much more willing to approach me to discuss things.  It bothers me when people make any sort of assumption about the eventual sexual orientation of children.  I try not to assume adults are straight until I have reason to think so, and I'm doing the same for my son.  

      • Show (0 / 0)

        Just wanted to clarify I wasn't sure I agreed with this wonderful Dr. Phil advice, it was just a show that stuck in my head!  

        I was actually surprised when he advised the mom to 'redirect' the son away from the girl stuff.

        I don't know Phil's politics, but I would assume his audience overall is mainstream-leaning-conservative, so it makes sense he would give this advice in that context.

        • Yeah, that's what I thought (0 / 0)

          I didn't think you were advocating the redirection.  I actually think mainstream thinking is becoming more open to kids playing with opposite-gender toys, but maybe I'm just spoiled from living in a very liberal area.

    • Dr. Phil is flippin' idiot (0 / 0)

      Man, I hate that snake oil salesman sleazebag hack.  What kind of advice is that?  There's this stupid double standard going on.  If this was Robby's daughter wanted to play with trucks and race cars, then this idiot would have been all "let her play with it, it's okay."  

      It's toys.  Why can't the the little boy play with the dolls?  My friend's son is almost 4 and he carries around a little baby in a pink bassinet almost all the time.  He's the least destructive male toddler I've ever met.  

    • every once in a while (0 / 0)

      I will hear of a piece of advice from Dr. Phil that makes a bit of sense to me.

      But usually - I too think he's a dipshit.

      But if you think about it, anyone who would actually take the advice of any TV personality all that seriously (beyond a book recommendation) deserves what they get (crappy, generic blather). IMHO, if you need a therapist or counseling for something - do it yourself. All situations are unique and individual and should be dealt with as such. Find someone who can look at you personally.

      I'm no fan of talk shows (tv or radio), can ya tell? Especially the advice kind.

      "the "well-informed citizenry" envisioned by our framers has degenerated into a "well-amused audience." Tad Daley, Alternet - interview w/ Al Gore 05/22/07

      by cgiselle12 on Wed Mar 28, 2007 at 10:33:48 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  • Pinky & Rex (0 / 0)

    Have you read the Pinky and Rex series of books?  Pinky is a boy who likes to wear pink, and Rex is his (girl) neighbor across the street.  They're good, your son might like them.

  • Girls & princesses (0 / 0)

    Kids don't know something's "different."  We put it in their heads.  My friend has a 2.5-year-old daughter.  Up until now, she never played with dolls or stuffed toys.  She loved the cat, looking at any animals, sticks, leaves, rocks, bugs.  We figured she was taking after her botanist father. This suited them just fine.  They had some pink and/or frilly things for her, but mostly just dressed her in cute, comfortable clothes she could play in.

    Last week my friend put on a skirt for work and DD said, "You're wearing a dress; you're a princess."  The next day DD wanted a mirror and a rose like Belle.  All of a sudden, it's full-blown princess frenzy.  She's seen the Disney videos and probably has girls in daycare who are into princesses, but my friend is really surprised to see it.  But I bet it's temporary.  How else do people figure things out unless they're willing to try different stuff?  Kids are great at that; we adults forget it.

  • Your title (0 / 0)

    I think there's something about that color that makes kids just gravitate toward it.  My daughter is all about pink, though she only has a few pink items, and it's funny watching my son get into her stuff and just get all the pink stuff.  The other day, my husband when to go check on the baby.  He went into the room to see the boy with Ilia's pink purse, skirt, perfume bottle and pencil case, wearing a pair of her pink underwear on his head.   DH started singing, "Pretty in pink, isn't heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee..."

  • The Simpsons (0 / 0)

    When Homer's shirts accidentally get washed with Bart's red hat, they all turn pink...

    Mr. Burns: "Ah Smithers, these color cameras are paying off already..."

  • I'll be a little contrary (0 / 0)

    I want to add that when I write words to songs in my elementary classes both boys and girls go crazy whenever I use the pink marker.  Weird.  It can even be a song they're not too thrilled about it-they get excited when I write the words in pink.  I have no explanation for it.

    I'm not sure I would dress my son in girl's clothes if he expressed an interest in pink. In this case, think I would probably go your mom's route and buy boy clothes that are pink only because I wouldn't want him to get mad at me when he's older.  Kids can be very cruel and I would also be afraid of him getting picked on if his future friends saw old pictures or something.  That's my two cents.  You do what works for you.

  • I like pink shirts (0 / 0)

    I'm talking about men's dress shirts that are light pink, not anything frilly or with flowers.  But I've always felt like it was a very attractive colour for a man to wear, and that it represented a secure masculinity.

    -Alan

Permalink | 31 comments