Mother Talkers

Why Is There No Respect for Care Givers?

Thu Dec 06, 2007 at 10:03:09 AM PDT

Because care givers from nursing home assistants to babysitters are in such high demand, I have often wondered why they are paid so little and under-appreciated in this country. Here is a provocative letter from a professional care giver posted on Berkeley Parents Network:

People's attitudes toward certain professions.
-------------------------------------------
I work in child care and find that people are often politely condescending to me until they realize that I am 'like them' - meaning that I am well educated, have a reasonably high family income, etc. Can I ask why? I know that there are a lot of people on BPN who use childcare and I am just curious why childcare workers are looked down upon.

I've chosen the profession because a) I love kids, b) I can take my kids to work with me, and c) I can make a (very) little money. My income isn't pertinent to our bottom line which allowed me to choose something I LOVE. Kids are awesome and I love to spend time with them. The whole experience also makes me a better mom. But, the parents...ooh, my. All are politely friendly (and usually ask within a few weeks of meeting me to be their personal nanny...even tell me that I can bring my kids with me and they will pay me a dollar more an hour than I am already making). Sometimes they make some vaguely condescending remarks. But, those that engage in a longer conversation with me usually ask 'why do you work here?' Even my own sister says that she pays her cleaning lady better than she pays her babysitters.

I realize that part of it is ego, but part of it is curiosity. I have always been appreciative of my caregivers contribution to my sanity and lifestyle. I am still on friendly with my old nannys (sic) (I like them as much as my friends and appreciate them as much). Can someone enlighten me as to why childcare has such a bad rap?
-anon

I do think it is an elitist attitude certain “white collar” workers have towards manual laborers, which is what caring for children feels like with the diaper-changing, dressing, clean-up, etc.. Also, we (unfairly) don’t view children as smart, thus feel that occupying them is a waste of a good mind. This is my guess.

Do you think we will ever compensate our care givers what they deserve? Why do you think we take care givers for granted?

  • ::

Tags: care givers, babysitter, nanny, daycare, nursing home, low pay (all tags)

Permalink | 14 comments

  • no idea (0 / 0)

    but it also begs the question of why we pay teachers so little, and lavish celebrities and professional athletes with more money than they could ever hope to spend. It all tells me something is seriously wrong with our society's priorities.

    We shared a nanny with a friend earlier this year and a few family members asked how much we paid her and I told them. Without fail, they expressed shock and insisted I was paying too much.

    The sad thing is I felt we were paying her a pittance, not nearly enough for the peace of mind she brought us, but it was what we could afford.

    To me, knowing someone is providing safe, loving care to your child is priceless and they deserve the utmost respect.

    • yeah, you know (0 / 0)

      I could never figure out why you'd want to low-ball the salary for the person who is going to be caring for your child. Lowest bidder is not a good thing here, people!

      • seriously! (0 / 0)

        People acted like I was a SUCKER...for wanting to pay THE PERSON WHO CARES FOR MY CHILD a decent amount! It's not like I had just bought a car or something...

        • This is one of my pet peeves, too. (0 / 0)

          I share a nanny with friends, too. And without fail, my family acted shocked at what she was earning. I said exactly what you said: She is offering me a priceless service and actually deserves much more than that. No way would I feel comfortable having a disgruntled person taking care of my child.

          • It's great to feel valued (0 / 0)

            Having been a babysitter for families in the past, I felt like what they paid me often showed how much the valued me.  Obviously, some families have less money than others, but there was one family who was pretty well off, but would pay me to the MINUTE.  So if I worked 3 hours and 45 minutes, and they paid me for 4 hours, they would tell me that I owed them 15 minutes.  The kids were great, but I really disliked babysitting for that family since I didn't feel valued.

            This isn't universal, of course.  There have been some families where I felt valued that didn't/couldn't pay as well, but you can show it in other ways.  In general, though, I plan to always be generous with caregivers since I'd rather have a happy person who feels appreciated taking care of my child.

  • playground divide (0 / 0)

    I live in a neighborhood where a lot of families use nannies.  I'm also younger than many of the moms around, so I've made friends with some younger nannies.  I consider the relationships to be pretty equal, although I'll sometimes forget that some of them don't have the same education I do when having a conversation.  (I mentioned something about the equator to an English-speaking Caribbean nanny, and she had no idea what I was talking about, although I consider her a very intelligent person.)

    I'm a teacher and did some summer child care a couple years before having my own kid, so I've been on both sides of it.  I also found I could make connections with parents when they realized I was one of "them," but generally found it easier to talk to other caregivers at the time.

    The issue has come up recently since I've been trying to organize a couple neighborhood playgroups where people would rotate homes.  There are some families who want their kids to participate, but the kids would come with the nanny, and people have mixed feelings about that.  I can see both sides of it, and don't feel strongly either way.  I think it's great to meet nannies and include working families in the playgroup mix, but also can see how parents home with their kids all day would rather establish relationships with other parents.  When you consider the topics that could come up (breastfeeding, postpartum issues, partner relationships, caregiver issues, bedtime, etc.), you can see how it could be good to keep it to just parents.  I've also found it awkward when I've gotten to know a nanny/kid pair and then meet the parents much later in the game.  I've even had parents give me creepy looks when I'm out in public and know their kid's name (but then I explain and it's usually OK).

    • I found the same thing (0 / 0)

      I tried to organize a playgroup with a group of little boys my son's age. In the mix were stay at home moms, a part time WOHM, and full time working moms. I specifically invited the working moms to send the boys with their nannies if that were easier. These  two families live right next door to me, so I thought this was going to be the easiest playgroup ever.

      But it didn't get legs. The working moms came when they could (it was very late afternoon deal), which wasn't often. None of the nannies ever came, even though I have good rapport with them and we spend time in our front yards, etc.

      I think it's a discomfort hanging out with your employer's friends/neighbors? I suppose it could be the topics that would come up, but only the caregiver issues one is clearly not appropriate. I personally wouldn't get into relationship issues during a playgroup. So I don't know, but it was a bummer.

      RachelD

      • It depends on the purpose of the playgroup (0 / 0)

        I think if your main goal is to have kids for your kid to hang out with, it's fine opening it up to nannies.  If your main goal is to develop long-term relationships and friendships with other parents, I can see wanting to keep it to just parents.

  • 'Cause we live in a patriarchy (0 / 0)

    And anything that remotely smacks of "womens' work" -- teaching, nurturing, making things run smoothly -- is devalued.

    We simply need more women -- more mothers -- in positions of power to start shifting these attitudes. And even then it won't happen overnight.

    • I think this is the main reason (0 / 0)

      People think of taking care of children as something that a teenage girl could do. So pay a "teenage girl" wage.

      It's hard to imagine this changing much in my lifetime.

      • I had a mother' s helper (0 / 0)

        come over one day...I gave her a paltry $5/hr to hang with my 2 kids and her mom made her give me back some money! Ack. From then on, I was only 'allowed' to pay her $3/hr.
    • Agree 100% (0 / 0)

      Like nurses, teachers, and any other occupations traditionally filled by women-- completely undervalued.

      I have enormous respect for caregivers-- I hope the caregivers I've worked with have felt that from me. Who knows.

    • Exactly. (0 / 0)

      I think it has little to do with "white collar" or "blue collar" or "manual labor" and everything to do with what's considered "women's work".  Notice that many semi-skilled blue collar jobs pay very well...we have nothing against paying welders or truck drivers decent wages (comparatively speaking).  

  • So sad! (0 / 0)

    I LOVE my daughter's caretakers. I adore them, they are fabulous... I hope they know how much I appreciate them! I try to give gifts and the like when I can, and have been collecting for the holidays- money is tight but they deserve so much! I guess it's just up to people like us who understand how valuable they are to tell them, all the time, and show our appreciation.

Permalink | 14 comments