Mother Talkers

Strong Enough To Be A Mom: Part Three

Mon Dec 17, 2007 at 07:45:10 PM PDT

So, it was summer 1999, my husband and I had passed TWO psychological evaluations, met with our adoption agency director without our attorney present, and we were slated to meet her again in a follow-up meeting. My husband was so fed up by the going in circles that he wrote down four possible choices for ending this situation. He first listed our preference, which was for the agency to write a letter to the Chinese authorities and ask that our adoption be completed by another agency. We had ZERO trust in anything the first agency said, and did not want to travel with their guide, since it was their facilitators who demanded we change our contract late in the adoption, not to mention the abusive phone call we received at home from one of their facilitators. The other choices were to let us get a referral and hire a guide, to go with their guide (which we did not want and would have needed assurances that he would not try to get more money or concessions from us in China) and the last choice was to end the adoption and find a financial settlement - which we really did not want to do.
I was never interested in suing an agency for damages, and willingly signed their very restrictive contract. I recall clearly at the time, looking at it - with all his qualifiers about the risks of adoption, basically letting them off the hook for giving us a two-headed baby - and I thought: "If they don't follow the rules, they should be arrested, not sued." We had to follow so many rules - our fingerprints were sent to the FBI. Shouldn't they respond with similar proof of their integrity?

The second meeting was not better than the first. The agency director began by cheerily telling us that we "passed" the three-hour home visit/psychological evaluation by her handpicked psychologist (and former employee). Well, duh. We knew we were sane, but had more and more doubts about the emotional balance of those with whom we dealt, but we couldn't turn around and demand a psych evaluation from them. My husband presented the four choices, and said we wanted an answer within the week. The agency director looked surprised and said, "This sounds like a negotiation!" What did she think we were there for? We wanted a baby. They prevented us from getting a baby. We were trying to negotiate a way to get a baby.

A few days later, our attorney called and said that the agency had agreed to let us transfer to another agency. Remember, a few months earlier, they had INSISTED that this was illegal and insulting to the Chinese. Now, they said, "Oh, okay." But first, we had to sign away our right to sue them for emotional damages. (Again, I wanted them in jail not sued.) We did this, withholding any claim to money but more importantly for us, we kept our right to talk to anyone and everyone about our situation.

So we waited for them to write the letter to the Chinese, asking to transfer our adoption to another agency. They had to write it, using the Chinese name under which they are registered in China. Through some detective work, we came to understand that the agency was NOT licensed to do China adoptions. Like a number of agencies, they "piggybacked" onto another agency's license, and submitted applications through that agency. This was completely secretive, and since we wanted to adopt, I did what I had to in order to push this along. Once our new agency (they were already working for us for free and trying to find out what happened in China) told us that the first agency had to send a letter on the letterhead of the actual, licensed agency, I called the licensed agency, located in another state. I called five days in a row and BEGGED them to provide the letter or the letterhead to let us complete our adoption. They, and they alone, were standing in the way of our completing our family. Further, the agency we signed with had created a big stinking pile of manure in China, with their name on it.

The licensed agency, located in Pennsylvania, refused to lift a finger for us. Well, they did lift a finger to call the agency lawyer and have him tell us to stop calling them.  Eventually, we got the letter handled and our new agency, a small one in Texas, learned some surprising facts.

First, when they took the letter to the Chinese authorities, they were told that the first agency's facilitator in China told them that we "hated China and were quitting the adoption." The release we signed included the statement that the agency had done NOTHING to damage our chances to adopt in China. The Chinese government was not at all happy to learn that we were nice people who were still trying, months later, to adopt. They also HAD assigned us a child - a daughter whose paperwork was returned (we still don't know the circumstances - if they forged our signature declining or what). We were relieved to hear that the girl was adopted some months later. Still, she had extra months in an orphanage because of the meanness of this agency and its facilitators.

In October, we received an email from our new agency's director, who was in China for meetings and happened to be present in the office when the Chinese assigned us a child. He wrote a short email about "Little Miss Tai Chunyang" who "did not like her photo taken - which I knew meant that the photo we would receive was UGLY but we were not worried about that, at this point.

The next day he emailed again. There was some confusion over the paperwork, and it turned out "Miss Tai" was in fact A BOY! I almost fell off the chair laughing. After all we had endured - we were getting a healthy boy! We further learned that he was really considered a terrific baby and many agencies and others had expressed the hope of getting him for one of their families.

The most amazing thing of all: when we later received his medical report, it turned out that he was born on April 9th. Remember how the agency sent us a letter that we received on April 8th, the one putting the adoption "on hold." April 8th here would be April 9th in China by the end of our day, so while our original adoption was stopped, in China a young woman was giving birth to our son!

Just yesterday, we celebrated our "Gotcha Day" - the day in December when we walked into a hotel in Nanjing and someone called his name and put a plump, happy and extremely adorable baby into my arms. That first photo was just taken on a day when he showed the force of his grumpiness, but when we met, he was content, took to us at once, and even today tells us that he wouldn't want any other parents. We seem to fit well as a family, and our boy is healthy and smart and can be as ornery as I am, which makes him an honorary Texan in my book! My mother had it in her heart that she was getting a granddaughter, but once she saw our baby, she forgot everything else and fell in love with him, as most everyone did when he was a baby.

We see now the strength we acquired from the adoption ordeal, and every bit of it was needed for raising him. We do believe we ended up with the "right" baby for our family. The agencies I mentioned are still operating, and all the complaint letters I filed, with documentation to the misinformation they gave us in writing, the contract demands and all - went nowhere. I helped another family later who had trouble with them and they ended up with a financial settlement that allowed them to adopt, but they could not talk. This is a clever way to shut down criticism. I kept talking, so much that I became unwelcome in local adoption support groups, which had many people who were happy with their adoptions through that agency. I learned a lot about adoption law - in this state, it only discusses domestic adoption, leaving a huge murky area for agencies to partner with any number of shady facilitators, demand bribes, etc. if they want, and parents are left to go along or go to mediation. We felt we could do an honest adoption, and we held to that. It should have been easy. Still, as our attorney said, in the end, WE won. We won because, despite all their efforts to make us quit, we still completed our adoption and got a wonderful and healthy child.

Tags: adoption (all tags)

Permalink | 14 comments

  • Yay! (0 / 0)

    what a fantastic end to the story!

    • somedays I can't believe we lived through it (0 / 0)

      In the middle of it, we really did feel like we were in Alice in Wonderland reality, where people said the most inane, confusing, nonsensical things as if they were ordinary common sense. And our brains were blinking red: WTF? WTF? WTF?!!!

      Then, when I took our boy back to China in 2005 and saw how he was the adored little prince in his orphanage - well, how much more blessed could we be than to have a child who spent 8 months in a Chinese orphanage being spoiled rotten?

      • Wow (0 / 0)

        Did your son get to meet his former caregivers? Awww, that is so great.

        Have you ever considered finding someone at a prominent newspaper to do a big feature on adoption agencies? Or is that an action too far? Because I am also thinking WTF as I have read your account.

        • our return to China (0 / 0)

          Our son not only met the former director(who had named him after her OWN SON) and the doctor (who kept photos of herself with our son - like "Grandma and baby" portraits) but he visited the babies who were there. The director took us around the city to see some of its interesting places, told us some information about the birthmother that she had learned, and when we drove away from the town, she burst into tears as the van left. I have kept her updated on his progress through the years so she has been able to see his growth and learn about his life. Ironically, if he had been adopted in China, even in the same city, she would have known less about him. Chinese still adopt and do not tell the child about the adoption, so my son knows about the people who "spoiled him rotten until Mommy and Daddy came to get him" while a Chinese kid would pass the welfare institute every day and know nothing about their kindness.  Right now I am quietly searching for his birthmother. This is not common with China - as the children are generally abandoned without identification - but I have some clues and helpful local people to press our case.

          See my post about reporters below.

      • typo - still learning to post diaries (0 / 0)

        I can't believe I goofed the spelling of my son's name! Sheesh! It is Tai Chunyang, nor Churning or whatever I wrote. I was really tired when I posted this.

        I tried to change it but wasn't sure - if I edit, then do I preview and publish again? I was afraid I would end up with two duplicates.

  • yeah to happy ending (0 / 0)

    I am so mad at those people! I hope you reported them to the Better Business Bureaus in your state and theirs. If they had been totally ethical, they would have told you that they worked through another agency. Argh. I wish I had faith that the Hague implementation in the US would fix these kinds of problems....but I don't.

    But I am glad it worked out in the end. What a story!

    • will do a followup on all the complaints I filed (0 / 0)

      I did try to interest a reporter in Pennsylvania, where the other agency(the one that had the license) was located(in Wynnewood)but she said, "Oh, after Hague is ratified, this will all end." Hah. The Better Business Bureau could only recommend mediation. The sw board found no reason to discipline the agency director. Ditto for the state licensing board for agencies. I even filed a complaint against the attorney.

      Again, what hurts is that when they are bad and settle with a family(I know of two cases already) these are not shown in the files if a person calls BBB or the state to find out their record.

      We were not the only family that balked at the change of contract, but others just went along with it. We did not think we were doing anything extreme - just saying, "Honor the contract we signed" but it rapidly went downhill.

      • complaints (0 / 0)

        Oh, Angelina's agency lol. I'm surprised at the naivete. maybe i have too many years in corporate life.....

        When we started on our adoption journey, I investigated domestic adoption for a while and interviewed one agency that told me that one client had filed a complaint against them. Very upfront. Told me all about it and I called BBB to find out. That made me more confident that they were ethical even tho we didn't go that route.

  • Thank You (0 / 0)

    Thank you so much for sharing your story.  I will remember this if we ever end up adopting.  Blessings to you and your family!

  • I'm so happy that you completed your family! (0 / 0)

    It did strike me as being very unusual that you got a son given the extreme bias towards boys.
    At the same time I believe it was meant to be!

    Would you consider adopting again to expand your family?

  • What a wonderful story (0 / 0)

    Thank you for taking the time to write it and share it here with us.
  • replies to everyone (0 / 0)

    Glad you liked the story. A lot better to read than to live through, believe me!

    If someone wants to adopt, please contact me for some hints on what to look for in an agency. Yes, in private I will name names of who to avoid.

    We won't adopt again. I am too old for China and would not meet new qualifications(amount of body fat, etc.)

    Even today, some agencies really inflate the healthiness and all of the children. Some will say, but never put in writing, that they have "special connections" to get the "best" babies. So, if you get a child with special needs, you might be shunned by other  families who used that agency and believe that they were treated to v.i.p. treatment with their adoption. You don't think that would happen? I heard from a family who had that experience. It is appalling to think that parents would create a snobbishness about their kids versus kids adopted from another agency, but they do.

    • re: wow! (0 / 0)

      so glad to get the whole story and that it had a happy ending-how unnecessarily heartrending and what a bad faith agency! Whew.

      Our adoption facilitator once said that adopting would have "unseen obstacles" and she was right, but NOTHING like your journey. I'm glad that you persevered!

Permalink | 14 comments