Mother Talkers

A Real Fu*k!ng Problem

Mon Jul 10, 2006 at 02:06:20 PM PDT

I have a confession: I suffer from a chronic case of potty mouth.

Now, I'm no Wanda Sykes. I don't pepper most of my sentences with F-bombs and other assorted expletives. But I have been known to use them when I'm angry, or impassioned, or when something I'm saying needs a certain...emphasis.

Which was all well and good...until I became a mother. Now I have a very precocious 18-month-old daughter with an ever-growing vocabulary, and the unnerving habit of repeating words at random when I least expect it.

Any day now, I fully expect her to bust out a cheery "Asshole!" during one of our morning drives to day care. But I'll blame that on the horrid drivers I must dodge to get her there in one piece...assholes...

In any case, this is a sticky issue for me. I once vowed not to morph into one of those uptight parents who tries to raise their kids in a bubble. And I never gave much thought to my language when there wasn't a tiny human in the house.

Now, I get annoyed when my husband plays a semi-violent video game in her presence. The hip-hop music he likes is now verboten when she's in the car with us; why didn't all the violence and misogyny in the lyrics faze me pre-baby?

I don't want to raise my daughter like a Pollyanna, but I don't want her suffering the same fate as poor Little Mr. Apricot, either. (Click on the link...you won't be disappointed!)

So, what's a modern mom to do? Should I set up a "swear jar" and contribute a buck each time I catch me or my husband swearing? Are there self-hypnosis tapes that can cure me of this awful affliction? Or should I just keep talking as always, and teach my daughter that certain words are for grown-ups only? Will that increase her chances of becoming a national disgrace some day?

The possibilities seem endless and confusing.

Makes me want to say, "Ah, fuck it."

What say you, MotherTalkers? Help a potty-mouthed parent out!

  • ::
Poll

Do you curse in front of your kids?

27%95 votes
21%72 votes
41%141 votes
9%33 votes

| 341 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: (all tags)

Permalink | 99 comments

  • i confess (0 / 0)

    i cuss all the time. it is pretty ridiculous. and not so bad as it sounds, because i also am known for using lots of legitimate words people have to look up in the dictionary or ask me to define.

    i just get fired up. i do not ever directly cuss to my son, and i do try to temper it. i am terrible when driving, to where i have even heard my son say to a car in front of us, "just go, lady!" (yikes!)

    the main thing that i try to focus on is context and content. we do not ever use words against one another in our house. calling names like 'stupid' or telling someone to 'shut up' to me are FAR more harmful than the frustrated expletive.

    speaking of which - )()(#%&)@(#$&_@#(%(@# - i am having a shitty day. so there!

    We cannot defend freedom abroad by deserting it at home. - E.R. Murrow

    by lorin on Mon Jul 10, 2006 at 02:54:15 PM PDT

    • swearing in front of children (0 / 0)

      Mine may be grown up now ... daughter just turned 20 and son is almost 22 but I do remember their early years with great fondness.

      And you will hear the language you use in front of them coming out of their mouths -- trust me on that.

      It astonished me the number of times that a 2, 3 or 4 year old said something that I know I said all the time.  

      So if you don't mind your children swearing at random then go ahead and don't curb your language.

      I chose to moderate mine.  

      • agreement (0 / 0)

        A friend of mine who is a mother too, was extremely liberal with her kids with regard to rule setting including their use of language.

        I think she was very sorry for that, the day her daughter called her a 'sorry sack of shit.'  

        Moderation is a pretty good way to go in most everything.

        It's work at our house.

  • fu*k!ng A (0 / 0)

    ok, i've almost stopped laughing - poor little mr apricot.  but the guy's comment at the end of the article about using the picture in question of little mr apricot with the caption 'screw oranges' is classic.

    i'm reminded of when my son was maybe 9 or 10.  during a conversation we were having (where i'm sure i must have been imposing some god-awful limitations on his self-described schedule of fun), he began rubbing his temples using only the middle finger of both hands...holy shit, i pondered, was he trying to tell me to fuck off?  

    the only recourse i could think of at the time was to mimic his behavior knowing that if he wasn't aware of what he was doing, no big deal, but if he did know......

    and i confess, i am not a big potty mouth since my late teens, and so now, when i do use expletives, my kids lose themselves in giggles - they are 15 and 19.

    recently we were playing scattergories and i had to come up with "something you yell" which started with an "m" --- you can imagine my daughter's surprise, when it came to yelling my word "MOTHERFUCKERS" in the middle of the game ---
    consumed by gales of giggles, she nearly rolled off the couch....

    i'm glad this is one aspect of parenting i do not have to consider too much any more....so fuckin' A, do whatever feels right.

    • mom's mouth (0 / 0)

      Karen m

       I can just see that scene with everybody ROFLTAO!!
      I'm with you. I figure my kids are hearing plenty of words used today as regular language than I did as expletives when I was their ages ( 14 & 20). My girls have listened to me yammer on - especially when listening to Air America and any political shenanigans these days and they just chalk it up to - yeah, that's just my mom...I love it that I can be real with them.

      • i'm with you (0 / 0)

        you are so correct....for a long time i was careful with language which struck me as  offensive to others so that my kids would know that there are appropriate and inappropriate places to say certain things...i confess i don't appreciate the unending use of the word f** coming out of the mouths of kids constantly...or the gangsta type bitch/ho etc. misogynistic language that is so prevalent now.  but my kids are hearing it all, all around them.  i know they don't add to much of it to the whirl themselves, but with their own peers, i'm sure they drop lots of f-bombs

        when my son was only about 3, we were in the grocery line about to check out when he said 'mom, my scrotum itches..'   it struck me as hilarious and it underscored the thinking at the time of giving your children the correct language to describe parts of their bodies....

        it's fun now with kids that are old enough that  much of the painstaking thought for this type of issue is long gone.

  • newsflash (0 / 0)

    Another item to consider when it comes to language and the use thereof:

    For those of you who watch what you  eat, here's the final word on nutrition
    and health and the possibility of language as a percursor to death. It's a relief to know the  truth after all the conflicting medical
    studies.

    1. The  Japanese eat very little fat and suffer fewer heart attacks than
    Americans.  
    2.   The Mexicans eat a lot of fat and suffer fewer heart attacks than
    Americans.  
    3. The  Chinese drink very little red wine and suffer fewer heart attacks
    than  Americans.
    4. The  Italians drink excessive amounts of red wine and suffer fewer heart
    attacks  than Americans.
    5. The  Germans drink a lot of beers and eat lots of sausages and fats and
    suffer  fewer heart attacks than Americans.
    CONCLUSION: Eat and drink  what you like.  

    Speaking English is apparently
    what kills  you.

    • I love that! (0 / 0)

      It will be a perfect little example to use in class if I ever teach critical thinking again.  It goes along the lines of everyone who has ever drank water has died; therefore, if you've ever drank water, you will die!
  • Cursing (0 / 0)

    My mother used to tell me that ignorant people used foul language because they could never think of an appropriate word to express themselves. What the f*** does she know?
  • Heather Armstrong has (0 / 0)

    some funnies about this on her blog

    http://www.dooce.com/...

  • one mother's opinion (0 / 0)

    I've never been good at keeping myself from cursing in front of my son and I have a pretty nasty mouth. Like a previous person said, I never curse at my son (or at anyone else, really). So far we've just explained to our son that some words are "grown-up words" and should only be said by grown-ups. It's worked like a charm so far. That tactic probably won't work everyone, but it works well for us.
    • exactly. Well, half of it (0 / 0)

      We do the same - we curse, but we are also pretty selective in what we curse about, and when. We've done the "grown up" words route, with great success - NOW. Big caution, there though - before they got that distinction there was one dropping of the F-bomb at day care, etc.

      OTOH, *nobody* in our house says things like "stupid," "fat," "hate," etc. Those are bona fide BAD words.

      • this gets sticky (0 / 0)

        So if fat is a bad word does it follow that the person is bad for being fat?  This one always wreaks a bit of havoc for me.  I think when the word fat takes on such importance and is labeled as so BAD and gets this incredible rap, kids and adults then feel really put down when they are indeed overweight, or in a word, fat...It seems like there is no way to get this one "right."

        Does anyone else think this way?  

        • Maybe it's the idea (0 / 0)

          that we don't call people "fat" as an insult.  Children will innocently ask "Why is that lady fat?" because they don't know another way to describe it.  But I think you can teach them that it's using the word to speak negatively about someone that's wrong or bad.
  • Your (expletive delted) problem (0 / 0)

    being a little further upstream in these things than you - ours is now 11 - I can tell you that you're not doing those of us who have watched their mouths any favors. I keep my viewing habits to myself but one night our son wandered into the living room while I was in the bathroom. I was under the impression he was asleep, but he got up to get a drink of water. On the tube was Deadwood and I found him watching Al in full roar.

    I shut the tv off in haste.

    He said, "I know those bad words, the kids at school use them all the time. They learned 'em from their parents.

    Thanks.

    Thanks loads.

    • He's 11. (0 / 0)

      Of course he knows those words.   You can try to raise him in a bubble and all but stuff (and I do mean stuff) gets through.  

      I hope that you took the opportunity to talk about language with him and didn't just describe the words as "bad".   It would have been a great opportunity to talk with an 11 year old about why people use that kind of language and how it would reflect on his character if he were to choose to speak that way.    

      If those words are deeply offensive to you then it would have been a great time to let him in on something important to you.    

      "Nothing worth having comes without some kind of fight. Gotta kick at the darkness til it bleeds daylight"

      by lonestar canuck on Mon Jul 10, 2006 at 04:57:06 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  • One of my favorite stories (0 / 0)

    from a friend:

    While driving with her 7 year old daughter in the back seat, she was cut off by another driver.  

    Friend:  (muttering) Stupid bitch!
    Daughter:  Ooo Mommy!  You said stupid!

    • What's a bad word? (0 / 0)

      I'm not a parent as of yet, but as an uncle it's fascinated me to see what qualifies as "bad words".  "Stupid" is a common one I've seen.  As a child I was convinced "suck" was a bad word because my parents heard me say it and well, you can guess what they thought it was.  

      The funny thing is though that most parents seem to have concern about their children using that language because it embarasses them in front of other adults.  It's this notion that it's not something children of good proper parents say and they feel like bad parents when their child says something like that at the wrong time.  

      Really what I think it boils down to though is just giving children a sense that words have an appropriate time and place.  That even relatively mundane words like "stupid" or "idiot" aren't appropriate in every situation.  That while you might throw a few f-bombs while driving in traffic doing it in class isn't acceptable.  

      • Sort of (0 / 0)

        It is definitely about how others perceive us, but it has nothing to do with good or bad parenting--at least for me. Swearing was great when I was 20, but I find it coarse now. Not offensive, just ugly, crude, unnecessary--not fine, in the sense of the finer things in life. It is not part of my desired self-image. It is not how I want others--including strangers and my own kids--to see me. And I think some good old-fashioned decency is just what the world needs. Manners and courtesy are the oil that keeps the social machine running smoothly.
      • not really (0 / 0)

        for us, it's about the intent. Swearing can be descriptive, fun, even complimentary.

        Saying "stupid" is never anything but hurtful.

        And that's why we don't do it.

    • "Stupid is a bad word mommy!" (0 / 0)

      I get that all the time... I try to tell her it's OK to call inanimate objects stupid.

      I do occasionally use the f-word in particular. I calmly have told her not to use those words, but not made a big deal of it, and that's worked out ok. I try to use other words when I can. I don't fit your poll because I use them and just feel guilty.

      But kids need a frustrated exclamation of their own. My favorite was from Spongebob: "Barnacles!"

      There are few things as cute as a two-year-old shouting "Barnacles!" at something. :-D

      So I have tried to adopt that for myself, but alas my daughter seems to have outgrown it.

    • lol (0 / 0)

      when my son was maybe 18 months, someone cut us off. I hit the brakes, my bag hit the floor, and he looked up and said "oh, shit".
  • We used a "cuss jar" (0 / 0)

    I definitely had potty mouth but wanted to stop.  We used a cuss jar with sliding scale punishments depending on the word, and repeat offenses within a limited time frame upped the ante (there are several $20 bills in there).  We told ourselves we would send the money to the worst place I could think of to make it work as a real deterrent--the RNC (Republican National Committee).

    It worked.

    But the money--and we're talking several hundred dollars here--sits in an envelope at home.  I could never bring myself to actually send it to them.

    • Us, too (0 / 0)

      That was the only way to curb our potty mouths when my kid was born.  My husband made the mistake of uttering the phrase "fucking door!" when he was having a problem with it, and my then 3-year-old daughter repeated that phrase the rest of the day.  Not funny or cute at all.

      Fortunately, a calm discussion of how that was a word we aren't supposed to say stopped her.  But the curse jar was what finally broke us both of the habit of swearing in front of her.

      For me, there are several problems with kids swearing.  There's the coarseness and incivility, the rudeness to others' sensibilities, the fact that your vocabulary should be big enough that you can find another word to express yourself, and the fact that kids already grow up way too fast.

      We say "barnacles" or "tartar sauce," like Spongebob, or we make up our own curses (a favorite right now is "Oh, pickles!"

    • If you're done with it (0 / 0)

      You could send it to a good cause.
  • there is a great episode (0 / 0)

    On HBOs Entourage where the agent is with his kids and wife, and realizes somethings amiss b/c his boss is there.

    Now this guy drops the F-bomb like its 1945. However its priceless to any adult when he says it in front of his kids...and has to say, "Now children thats a daddy word, only daddy gets to say that."

    Okay its better on DVD.

    I tried!

  • Be prepared (0 / 0)

    to be embarrassed to death. You're little darling will have perfect timing in using the F word in a public place while you are trying to impress others. On the other hand, children understand early on when it is ok or not to swear. When my son was four, he asked me one day if he could say "shit." I paused a moment and thought, well, his dad says it all the time. I don't want to be hypocritical. So I said, "You can say it at home but not at Calvina's." (Calvina was the daycare provider.) "Oh, I know," he replied, "at Calvina's you say, 'God Damn it."
  • Here's what I did. (0 / 0)

    We did try to watch our mouths when the kids were very small. Still, between my husband and his mother (who swears like a sailor), Words Not Repeatable In Church were acquired by our sons.

    When the first said, "Oh, damn!" one day I looked at him and said, "M, you know there are things you can't do til you're bigger, right? Like driving the car?"

    He nodded solemnly, and repeated that he had to be as big as his cousin L (sixteen) to do THAT, or he'd be in trouble with the police.

    And we went over that you had to be as tall as the mark on the wall to cook on the stove, so you could reach things properly and not burn yourself, and he nodded and agreed.

    And I explained that that word was a way that adults got anger out when they were very frustrated, and that they weren't to be driven by little boys. He could use "darn" instead.

    The bonus of this method is that one can then look over at a small child and say, with great placidity, "P, you aren't old enough to drive that word. 'Fudge', please." It takes all the fun out of shocking the parents with it. (grin)

    And it seems to have worked so far (11 and 6)

  • Language (0 / 0)

    A: Yes.  Maybe more than I'd like to.

    My wife mutters "fuck!" as she parallel parks.  Then my son later says "fuck!"  while I am parking!  Like it's what you say when you park.  I laughed.  He now has a better understanding of the word and no longer (mis)uses it.

    Friend says 'as long as they don't use it with me...'.

  • Kid with bad language (0 / 0)

    My wife and I have never refrained from swearing in front of our daughter, now 11 years old. However, NEVER have we sworn AT her (or at each other, for that matter). My wife in particular finds it impossible to drive a car without colorfully cursing all other drivers on the road.

    But our daughter understands quite well when such language is appropriate -- at school, in public, in front of other adults, or at grandma's house. So far she's proven very reliable in sticking to that. But she'll shout "son of a bitch" when getting killed in a video game at home, or wax poetic about what an asshole George Bush is (I wonder where she picked THAT up...?)

    We all have that "internal mental filter" we engage for speaking to strangers in "polite company" so we don't blurt out "Jesus motherfookin' Christ" at a job interview. With our daughter's case, it seems to be working as well as any adult's.

    • same here (0 / 0)

      my kids are 14, 16 and 17 and they know when to keep it chill -- heck, they are three of the most repected kids in our community: in school, at their employment and among their peers. I think when you make a big deal out of something it becomes a big deal. In raising them I made a big deal out of them having good character -- being honest, being caring and being informed, you know, liberal values -- everything else is small stuff. The more you absolutely forbid something, the more attractive and desirous that thing becomes.

      -Donailin

  • This one is easy... (0 / 0)

    When you have a child, things change. You begin to re-think everything, beliefs, denials, you name it. Your childs' personality is already there and it will only be clear to you as they grow older and you look back at photos and videos.

    No one wants to hear a child say a curse word, especially daycare, school, out in public. They pay attention to your every word even if it doesn't look like it. I mean, that is how they learn their language, by listening.

    So much to worry about as a mom and if you'll make the right decisions while raising them. This one is easy...don't do it. They are a gift, precious. The least you can do is watch your mouth.

  • i definitely (0 / 0)

    dont want to make it taboo, but i probably exaggerated how much i cuss in my first post because  my day has been so hard.

    if i hear my son say 'damn' or the like when he cant get a toy to work, i immediately follow up with a more appropriate word, or let it slide. it only takes a few times of replacing with darn to help him (and me) form a better habit for those frustrating moments.

    i also find that giving him the actual words for the emotion are helpful, though he is still a little reticent to tell me he is mad or angry at me. this is despite me driving it home that he can be mad at me and i will still love him. this is one of the most important lessons my mother taught me. i am sure that will come in time, including, "i hate you mom!"

    i do not even like using 'stupid' for inanimate objects. dumb, idiot, etc... they just seem like such put downs, i have never liked them.

    We cannot defend freedom abroad by deserting it at home. - E.R. Murrow

    by lorin on Mon Jul 10, 2006 at 06:35:58 PM PDT

    • The less complicated the better (0 / 0)

      When kids are so young, I mean under 5, I think it's better to limit the swearing. Mostly because it's so complicated! People swear casually in conversation, sort of as a filler, and they swear out in frustration, or they swear AT other people. So kids get confused I think. I'm not prone to swearing unless I'm really upset or shocked or injured, so my daughter doesn't hear it from me. But, I'd almost rather she heard it the way I do it instead of from daddy -- the casual "n'shit" style of swearing. Once they get older, sure, they're going to hear cussing, but at least they can better understand the explanations about why someone is swearing, and why they shouldn't do it yet.

      I agree with you about not making a big deal about if your kid hears something colorful now and then, and trying to build their vocabulary so they can express themselves better when really upset. Incedentally, I never once told my mom I hated her, and I think part of that is because it was one of those words that I wasn't allowed to use casually. "Hate is a very strong word" she would say -- "Do you really HATE your shoes?" So I think I really took it to be a powerful word and could never bring myself to think it about my mom, let alone say it, even when I was furious!

  • swearing when the kids are around (0 / 0)

    I did not do too much when my kids were little but now, well, I outdo my son a little.  My daughter (both are in their 20s) is a little more moderate/genteel, whatever.

    Once when they were little and playing across the street, the father from that house came over and asked my husband and me which one of us swore "like a Banshee."  I had to confess.

    I think the important thing, as someone wrote, is teaching them when it's OK and when it's not, and they have to have some level of understanding and maturity, as well as inclination to cooperate, in order to follow those rules.

  • Can't help it. (0 / 0)

    Sometimes I find myself trying to find creative new ways to use bad words.  Hey...at least this stretches the kids' creative skills, right?

    I did keep it to a minimum when my kids were small.  Never a problem with the girls.  Dare I say it?  I think boys are born with a "cuss gene".  From the time they were school age, its like they had a natural desire to be potty mouthed.  We didn't freak...we've just always maintained a rule that some things can be said in the home but not in public.  We also drew the line between "bad words" and true obscenity.  As my kids became teenagers and older teenagers I would often remind them that using too much profanity just indicates poor verbal skills and laziness.  

  • it makes you think (0 / 0)

    I work with preschoolers and you can kind of get an idea of what the home climate is like by listening to them.  I remember a 4 year old boy pulling a girl off a trike and saying, "That's what you get, bitch!"

    I talked long and straight to this child's mother, who was in a violent relationship and felt really powerless to leave.  I tried to use her son's adoption of the abuser's language to give her a little more incentive to make a change.  I was trying not to guilt-trip her, but also letting her know that little pitchers have very big ears.

    I also remember my mother telling us when we were kids that we were allowed to say "hell."  No more H-E-double hocky stick.  It was such a thrill!  And then we got over it.

    I swear like a sailor now, but I really try to tone it down around my son.

  • maybe (0 / 0)

    you could try growing up.
    • aw, c'mon (0 / 0)

      try for constructive criticism, Anonymous!
    • hmmm (0 / 0)

      I think that's what we are all doing here, one day at a time.  And "growing up" has lots of connotations.

      I am a fully grown up woman, who having actually been a professionally sailor at one time in my life have acquired many very colorful expletives and in more than one language too.  While I definitely have watched my language with my children, I am no saint and in traffic or working on something particularly difficult, a bad word or string might slip out.  I am human.  

      If my children are present, then I explain what the word means and why I used it and I set limitations on their saying that word and why its not appropriate.

      I am grown up; however, I can honestly say I don't require that others don't cuss around their children.  Nor would I feel comfortable telling them to "grow up"  Seems very judgmental.

      Maybe its just me....:-)

      • were you in the Navy, Anne? (0 / 0)

        I love it - there just seems to be more and more coincidences here. My maternal grandfater was a commodore in the Navy, a cousin of mine served in the Navy as a deep sea diver, and my sister was considering the Navy post-college ... but then Dubya won in 2004 and she decided she couldn't serve that commander in chief.

        (Having made my initial comment, I am studiously ignoring the Anonymous parent quote that we both commented on.)

    • a puzzlement (0 / 0)

      since this is a naturally occuring phenomenon...i guess we are left to ponder,
      WTF?

      wishing you a good night's rest, and a better day tomorrow.

  • What not to do... (0 / 0)

    watch Deadwood on a regular basis. Only idiot-box I watch. It's f*cking brilliant! ;-)
  • I was lucky, but my kids aren't (0 / 0)

    I grew up in a family that did not swear.  When my Dad was mad, and we heard damn, it was the end of the world.  That happened maybe less than a dozen times in my whole life.  Each event was actually something pretty serious.  That the worst I ever heard from my Father, the word damn.  My mother never swore.  I did as a teenager.  But I got to the point where I learned to stop.  Then I joined the Army and they broke me down to the point it all came out.  But I got it back together and stopped.  I made the effort to not swear in the Army and was pretty good in the attempt.  It drove people crazy that I didn't.  But it did get me a lot of respect as well.  When I got out of the Service and went to college I had no need to swear.  But I ran into an old girlfriend and we eventually got married.  She didn't wait until we got married as she promised to have a kid.  So I learned not to trust the her on the pill.  But that is an other story.  But once together she showed her true colors.  It continued after we were married.  She was as nasty a mouth as anyone I've ever heard.  She had also kids from a previous marriage.  She swore in front of them, and at them all the time.  She didn't do this in front of me when we were dating.  We also had two daughters who have had to endure this kind of lanuage.  When her oldest son swore for the first time in front of me it was verbatum what his mother always spewed out of her mouth.  I once even made a large banner that said "please don't swear" with a bandaid on it to get my message across.  I still try my hardest not to swear, especially in front of kids.  Now her kids are grown and out of the house and all swear too much.  My 17 y.o. daughter is too much like her mother and a real potty mouth.  My wife swears at just about everything, often for no reason.  I pity our dog, as it usually gets the first of the morning curses.  Dogs are funny, because it is so loyal to my wife and gets so much verbal abuse.  I guess it helps if you don't understand the lanuage.  If it wasn't for the kids I would have left years ago.  But they seemed to have been stratigically planned.  I came close several times and could have taken my girls away from the endless vulgarity, but didn't.  No matter what, my wife is still their mother.  I put up with it as best I can.  But it is real hard.  My grandfather is the one who got me to thinking years ago.  He told me those that swear are too stupid to think of something better to say.  Besides being just rude.  He was right.  I've learned to come up with something better to say more times than not.  Often it is humorous in nature, or a pun.  Still, I was lucky.  My parents didn't swear.  
    • Too stupid to think of something better to say? (0 / 0)

      I roundly reject this argument.  On the contrary, I think that often people swear because there is nothing, out of the hundreds of thousands of words in the English language, better to say in certain situations than a swear word.

      Having a good vocabulary doesn't mean using big and obscure words to convey your meaning, it means using the right word.  Too many people, in an attempt to look smarter than they are, will use a big word where it is completely unnecessary, resulting in a muddled sentence with mixed connotations that obscure what the speaker/writer is trying to say.

      That being said, I think it's obvious to everyone that swear words, by their very nature, pack a certain linguistic wallop that other words lack.  When you drop something heavy on your foot, or whack your forehead against a door frame, or accidentially crush your thumbnail with a ballpeen hammer, are you really saying that there are words that can succinctly express the mixture of pain, shock, and anger better than any number of swear words?  It is precisely the taboo surrounding them that gives them their potency.

      With that in mind, people should curb their swearing, but not for the reasons you suggest.  The problem isn't that there's too much rudeness going around, the problem is that if people swear too much, the words lose their potency and their linguistic purpose (of course, when this happens new "taboo" words arise to take their place through the magical process of the dysphemism treadmill.)

      I think children should be taught how to swear properly, not that they should never swear.  But then, I don't have any moral qualms with swearing itself, so I guess that makes me look at this issue through an entirely different lens.

  • Potty mouth (0 / 0)

    Years ago, I was visiting my family with my potty-training toddler, Nora. She disappeared into the bathroom and then reemerged in the living room, naked, hands on hips. "Okay," she barked, "Where's the fucking toilet paper?!!" Oops. My family burst into laughter, and my self-rightous brother ripped into me: "How can you laugh at such behavior?!" I shirked: "Kids say the darnest things!"
  • You can only delay the inevitable. (0 / 0)

    Short of keeping your kids locked in a dungeon, you'll never be able to prevent them from being exposed to swear words.  I myself first started using them as early as second grade, though I didn't feel comfortable using them in everyday conversation until five or six years later.  By the time I was in high school, my parents, realizing the foolishness of it, lifted the swearing ban in my household.  Surprise, our relationships became closer, as both parents and children were able to speak to each other as they would speak to their peers.

    Which leads me to my broader point: for what reason would you speak to a child any differently than you would speak to a peer?  As several other commenters have said, so long as you explain to them the concept of swearing, and the proper contexts for its use, what exactly is the big problem with swearing?  They're just words.  If you teach them properly, they'll never swear in any situation where you wouldn't.

    This argument falls along similar lines as arguments made by child psychologists who discourage "baby talk."  Studies have shown that "baby talk" hinders a child's linguistic development severely, and can lead to speech impediments or even learning disabilities, especially when parents use it almost to the exclusion of normal language.  I would argue that placing an unspoken ban on swearing also hinders a child's linguistic development, though not as severely.  Why create an unneccessary taboo when you can simply teach them how to swear: they're going to do it anyway, might as well use some parental judo and roll with it.

  • I try not to swear (0 / 0)

    but have to say something. I've settled for "For Gawd's sake!". Not God, I hasten to add, but the London-style Gawd which has no religious meaning.

    This is all very well but it is very disconcerting when you spill cornflakes all over the floor and hear your 32 month old mutter through gritted teeth say: "For Gawd's sake!"

    But that is the way it has to be, as I just can't not say anything when I do things like that!

    • But can you really say that? (0 / 0)

      Can you really say that Gawd has no religious meaning?  Every time you say it, does it not run through your mind that "I am using this word instead of the word God?"  Even in your post, you felt the need to capitalize Gawd, much in the same way one would capitalize God.  If Gawd has no religious meaning, what is its meaning?  Other than "a euphemism for 'God,' " that is.

      This is another problem I see with efforts to curb swearing.  What is the point of saying "crap" or "poo" or whatever instead of "shit," when all of those words mean "excrement"?  Clearly, the concept of fecal matter isn't what's offensive, it's those particular phonemes that make up the word "shit."  Why?  What's so bad about saying "shit," if you can say "crap," which means the same thing and is used in the same context?  What is it about an post-alveolar-fricative consonant followed by an short-front-close monopthong vowel followed by an alveolar stop that upsets people so much?

      • Since you're being snooty... (0 / 0)

        That would be "a" (not an) and "monophthong" (with a second h). And you left out "unrounded." At any rate, it's not the phonlogy that matters--it's the cultural attribution of symbolic meaning to the utterance.
      • Hilarious! (0 / 0)

        Gawd is an old London saying. To me it means nothing other than the word gawd. But as I am posing on a US site I thought I would explain its origins as I see it. When I say it I don't think of God at all. If I wanted to say for God's sake I would. But I don't. I like the endearing nature of Gawd. It summarises the part of London that I am from aptly and is something my family has always said.

        Anyway, where's your fucking sense of humour for Gawd's sake?

        • And why has Gawd got a capital letter? (0 / 0)

          Because I love the word.

          Much like I love the word Twont which I use for people with few social skills.

          • I love British English! (0 / 0)

            I lived in England for about six months, and can't fake an accent, but learning the different words is almost like having another language.  One word I always liked is "yob."  It seemed a good description of the skate punks who used to hang around outside my building, smoking & shoving each other.  I could walk past & mutter "bunch of yobs" and they had no clue what I was saying.
            • Yeah it is pretty mad (0 / 0)

              I should point out here that Gawd is the cockney pronounciation of God. But, to me, it's just a London saying and it doesn't mean God to me!

              Gawd Blimey, etc is a twist on the saying "God Blind Me". From that very example you can see how the cockney Londoners used language to form their own language. And then it loses its original meaning, hence why when I say it I don't even think about God. Just like when I say dog and bone, I don't visualise a dog and a bone but a telephone.

              Confused yet? I'll leave out post-modern new wave cultural London rhyming slang!

            • British English (0 / 0)

              dunno - I find British English cursing to be far more direct and insulting. For example, the "c" word for female genitalia is dropped with shocking regularity, which is something I never got used to. To me, the "c" word is right up there with the "n" word as the most insulting things you can ever say to someone.
  • Funny story (0 / 0)

    Daddy is pulling out of our alley to take Willie to day care one morning.  There's truck blocking his path.  He says, "Oh, f*%^."

    Willie is in a parroting stage.  He says, "Oh f*%^?"

    Daddy says, "Oh TRUCK.  I said 'truck.' There's a truck blocking our path."

    Willie says, "Oooohh."

  • What about fart? (0 / 0)

    I just had another thought and I could use some input.  Is the word "fart" a bad word?  My mom and my MIL claim it is.  MIL wants us to use the (I think) absurd and ambiguous verb "puffing" to mean the same thing. Puffing, I say?  WTF is that?

    Willie has already incorporated "fart" into his vocabulary and uses it in situationally appropriate ways (e.g., "I'm not pooping.  I'm just farting.").

    So, to fart or to puff, that is the question.  What do you think?

    • the word makes me laugh (0 / 0)

      i'm smiling and laughing just thinking of the word fart and reading your comment.  a comment awhile back relayed that 'suck' was a bad word when he grew up --- same in my house....that has been hard for me to hear so much in the last 5-8 years --- even teachers at school use it all the time....my ears want to fall off my head when i hear it.

      a friend of my daughter's used to say 'air biscuit' which i thought was a funny and apt subsitution.

      but we use fart routinely in our house (probably not in public - except to gasp, and say on a crowded elevator, 'ok who FARTED?' jk)...but our kids are older....

    • we changed it a little (0 / 0)

      with all my familiarity with sailors language, I somehow had a difficult time hearing my adorable daughter say the word "fart".  So innocently one day we changed it to "part", she doesn't know the difference and in public no one has a clue what she's talking about.
  • foofs to farts to $%%!! (0 / 0)

    I had a family which used a lot of swearing and generally had what I call "emotional incontinence." Just let any old thing be expressed. Now, I have similar traits, but with a son who naturally has a hot temper and low tolerance for misbehavior of others(he will tell me to ram other cars who are in our way, for example) I have decided that I need to be the one with CHARACTER and DISCIPLINE, in other words, the parent.

    It is not easy, but I ask myself daily if I want to raise a verbally abusive little smart ass or a kid who can hold his tongue, use appropriate words, and find a way to understand others instead of just swearing at them? Hey, I am 54 and mad as anyone else at Bush, but when my son suggests that Bush should be beaten to a pulp, I remind him that Bush is an adult who makes BAD CHOICES and we always wish him well, to make GOOD CHOICES instead.I don't want him to think (when he is seven) that some people are a lost cause- because to me, that leads down the road of racism and bigotry.

    My husband and I had to decide early to find mild substitutes for swears - many came from our son's preschool, calling farts "foofs" was a big success. He did not switch to farts til the first grade, when making art farts was the height of boy humor. I will still use the word "foof" with him. When he is mad he sometimes says "CURSE YOU!" like he hears in cartoons, but when he asks me what it means, I tell him that when we wish harm and suffering to someone, that is what a curse is. I ask him not to say curse words(and yes, as another poster mentioned, my son also thinks "stupid" is a curse") and just try to get him to say what he is bothered by, not just call names.

    I am not saying this cures him - as I mentioned, he has a natural tendency to be judgemental and harsh. I can just model the best behavior I can.

    Of course, once in awhile he says something mean and I just say, "Oh, please don't say that - you kiss your MOMMA with that mouth!"

    • hot topic (0 / 0)

      great comment, and good thinking.  

      although 'foofing' in our house means my husband and i will be meeting in the bedroom for a romp.

      • meant ARM farts not art farts! (0 / 0)

        Sheesh! Nothing artistic about them at all! Althought I have a brother in law who used to smear his...well, you know, he was a kid.

        I think the emergence of IM abbreviations helps my husband and I too. We can be discussing something in the room with our son and look at each other and say, "W T F?" etc. using the letters,and he ignores it. But we also have adopted the cartoon "swears": "Cheese and crackers!" is a favorite.

  • we still swear too much (0 / 0)

    But now at least it's not 'flavoring' our speech (e.g., "I can't believe how fucking dirty the kitchen is!") but rather expressing shock or pain (e.g., "SHIT! THAT HURT!")

    The other day I was at the grocery, and having buckled my son into the car I was returning the cart to the nearest cart return. It was hot, I was sweating in a black shirt, and I was rushing to get back to the car. The cart return was too full.

    "FUCK!" I said, and as I looked up, I saw the horrified face of a 4-year-old, and the bordering on genuinely angry face of his father as they got out of their car. I actually began to try to explain myself (why?!), but he rushed his son along like they had to avoid the axe-murderer lady.

    I felt sheepish but even more mad. I'm six months pregnant, dammit, and the cart return was full! My toddler son is sitting in the hot car and I don't want to go back, unbuckle him, and carry him back into the store to take this freaking cart back! That's a moment for an expletive if ever there was one!

    I am pretty good at putting on a 'professional' mouth for work and so forth, but that incident made me realize that I need to be more sensitive to others around me in all situations. Dammit.

  • Earmuffs! (0 / 0)

    My husband loves that part from the move "Old School" and wants to use it with our son.  I was definitely not allowed to curse as a child, and my parents made it very clear that any cursing they did was an adult privilege only, and never taking the Lord's name in vain.  I think that's why I went through a period in 5th or 6th grade where I had the filthiest mouth on the playground.

    I'm still fairly free with my language, but like many of you, now I'm more concerned with context.  I don't think I'd mind if my kid said "shit" if he banged his finger in a drawer, but I'd be terribly upset if he called a little girl a bitch.

    But kids do go through phases when they're trying to test or shock you.  One evening when my niece was about five, she turned to my husband and said "piss."  He said very calmly, "That isn't funny."  Then she came over to me and said the same thing.  I said, "Nobody thinks you're cute when you do that."  She never did it again.  However, I learned later that she was fond of saying it in front of her mother, who would fly into a panic like it was the end of the world.  Guess the kid got the reaction she was looking for!

  • Ouch! (0 / 0)

    Nothing like being told it isn't cute to curb a little kids behavior! Good call!
  • kid who reads a lot (0 / 0)

    Generally, we tell our son (8 years old) "it's inappropriate to say that" if he uses a swear word, if he talks back, if he contradicts us, if he says something inappropriate to his younger sister.  Sometimes we'll add "those words are for when you get bigger". It a generaic phrase that avoids the guilt of "good" or "bad" language, and leaves open the possibility that in some situation it just might be appropriate. We feel that this defuses the situation. It also provides a structure for guiding non-swear language (like, say, demanding or disrepectful phrases).

    However, he does read a lot. He picked up "blast it" from Sherlock Holmes (or it might have been Moby Dick, or Treasure Island, I'm not sure). It's really funny to hear him mutter "blast" when he's trying to build something with Legos. He picked up "you fool" from the Redwall books (and when I heard that, I told him it was inappropriate, especially since only the bad guys in the stories say that phrase). He will occasionally say "damn", but usually when he's alone.

    It's worked pretty well. I think he understands that context matters. He also understands that there are things he's not allowed to do "until he gets bigger" (like wear his hair long like his father, cook, work with power tools, etc).

    So far my daughter hasn't started using inappropriate language, probably becuase she's heard my son begin chided for it.

    We rarely use insulting language of any kind to each other, so that kind of use hasn't really been a problem with my kids.

    We homeschool, so they are not exposed to the language of other kids very much. By the time we send them to school, I think they'll be old enough to understand that context matters.

    -Corinna

    • smiling (0 / 0)

      my son is also an avid reader --- always had a book everywhere he went since the time when he was an emerging reader.  he's 19 now and i greatly enjoy hearing his use of words --- often when he is angry or frustrated he will exclaim "Mother of Pearl"  or "blast" ....

      Being 6'4" and quite the manly specimen now, there are times when he uses profanity --- it doesn't bother me, because he uses it sparingly and his use of this kind of language has grown with him in what i consider an appropriate way.

      when he comes home from working in 100 degree weather all day on a construction site and exlaims "it's fucking hot out there..."  i couldn't agree more.

  • Its not the word, its the delivery (0 / 0)

    Great thread, and a topic on my mind quite a bit these days as our daughter becomes more verbal.

    I've noticed in these comments that the most frequent trigger is some trivial aspect of the driving experience (getting cut off, parking space "stolen," the car in front of you not peeling rubber the second the light turns green, etc.).  Our daughter's first curse was when she was in her car seat.  My wife hit the horn when we were stuck in traffic, and from the back we heard "asshole."  Which I think is the point.  I don't think there is anything inherently wrong with most "dirty" words, but cursing overwhelmingly occurs in response to a mildly aggravating situation, and models petulant anger and lack of self-control.  

    In the typical car scenario, it is not hearing any particular word that is destructive, but hearing the angry tone, seeing the finger, the violent gestures, the angry faces, pounding on the horn, drivers yelling at each other, tailgating, etc.

    I don't really care if my daughter learns most words (for me, racial/ethnic/religious slurs remain taboos).  I very strongly DO NOT want her to learn that the way to handle frustration is through self-indulgent, petulant anger and lack of self-control.

    The notion that profanity can only be a substitute for a proper word and a marker of low verbal ability is absurd.  On the other hand, the notion that we are all a bunch of George Carlins, turning cursing into high art, is equally absurd.  Having a daughter has made me reevaluate my cursing, and I now do it much less over all, and very rarely in front of her.  More importantly, I try very hard not to model anger and loss of self-control over trivia.

  • Potty-mouth backfire (pun intended!) (0 / 0)

    Well, I won't have a kid of my own to swear in front of for 2 more months... but I did just get back from a week with my husband's family, including his 6-year-old nephew who's just discovered the joy of bathroom humor.

    My husband's family is quite conservative and religious. My husband claims that he's never heard either of his parents swear in his life, and that he's never sworn in front of them either. (Wow.) The 6-y-o is the only grandchild so far, and his parents and grandparents have adopted a "zero tolerance" policy toward his rude language. We're not even talking F-bombs here; the kid can't even say "poop" or "butt" without four adults jumping down his throat and threatening him with timeouts.

    The strategy has completely backfired. The 6-y-o now talks of nothing but poop, farts, and butts. I can't tell if it's the normal love of bathroom humor that every 6-y-o boy has, or the fact that he's an only child, and will use any means necessary to keep the attention on him, even if it's negative attention. All I can say is that the more he gets yelled at for his potty mouth, the more he does it.

    In my 3rd trimester perfect-parent fantasies, I don't intend to swear in front of my kid (My husband and I are trying to transition to the "Oh sugar!" "Oh fudge!" exclamations that we remember from our own childhoods - they're hilarious!) or to let it slide when they start swearing. cynmill's reaction (i.e.: no freakout) seems to be the way to go, however - the less attention the kid gets for being rude, the better.

  • a memory (0 / 0)

    all this talk about language, reminded me of when our family was involved in a local  community swim team.  there were about 240 swimmers each summer that would span the ages between gutter guppies (3 years - 5 years) and older swimmers up to 18.

    in all the years my kids participated in this sport on this particular team (over 10 years), the language used poolside never included swearing -- i look back and think of that, and it seems amazing....but

    the team often used email as a way to communicate lots of info - updates, revised scheduling for practice etc...

    one day i opened an email which had been sent out to the entire team --- we're talking lots of families -- the email was flowing with wild and what i considered, hateful language.  one of the male coaches (then a student a princeton) was emailing his college buddies about an upcoming trip they were all taking to las vegas and all the "bitches and whores" they were going to encounter and "entertain" and be entertained by.  the email was filled with content that was clearly hateful and in my view disgusting.  it was such a shock to me and took me days to figure out my reaction and feeling about this person and the fallout from the unintentional emailing to the whole swim team list.  i felt really angry at the time and in some ways the emotion was tied to my wanting to rail against that kind of terminology for my daughter's sake.

    a week or so later, i ran into a different coach whom i admired a great deal (she also happened to be a student at princeton).  i considered her to be very intelligent and i wondered what she thought of this email and the language that was used in it.  i had assumed that she would be offended.  

    and yet, this very smart, beautiful, athletic young woman told me she wouldn't necessarily be offended by that language.  it would depend on who said those words and in what context.  i was blown away.  i couldn't imagine the context that would make that language ok ....i felt and still do feel that those kinds of labels/words are filled with hate and demeaning messages.

    i feel sad for all our daughters who are growing up during a time when being called bitches and whores is as if those words mean nothing at all.

    i couldn't disagree more.

    • grrrr (0 / 0)

      very few things make me madder than this.

      in the reverse, it would just never seem right to me to refer to a group of guys as assholes, as in 'i hooked up with these assholes.' you just dont hear that from women.

      i despise put downs of any kind, and i also have no understanding of that terminology being ok at all.

      We cannot defend freedom abroad by deserting it at home. - E.R. Murrow

      by lorin on Tue Jul 11, 2006 at 01:05:17 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  • I am vulgar and I feel I have the right to be (0 / 0)

    My kids are all on high school. They hear me curse all the time. Mostly the f-word as in "my head is going to fucking explode if I hear George Bush speak another sentence, someone shut him the fuck up"  

    and

    "These refucklifucks are determined to bring the end of the world on"

    it's like that. But it is SITUATIONAL.

    the thing is? Before the run up to the iraq war, I was extremely conscientious about my language. But as the lies increased, so did my vulgarity.

    I lament very often that I long for the day that there is no more righteous anger -- because that is what this is about -- and that my vularity will dissipate relative to justice being done.

    The comfort is this, though: I live in affluent suburban maryland and my clients -- many of whom are moms with elementary school kids, CATHOLIC elementary school -- are just as bad if not worse. I heard a mom who is practically known as a saint use the word "fucktard" and "god-damned"  a few weeks ago. I. Was. Floored. And I have a client who is 87 years old Irish and Catholic, she gives me a look if I let the word "shit" slip out. Well a month ago she referred to her ex-daughter-in-law as a "bitch".

    I could not fucking believe it. I've known her for six years and she never so much as used the word "hell" even as a reference to a location. Now she's a liberal, an FDR liberal and if she's feeling it and expressing it, than I know I'm in good company.

  • My mom never swore til she got HBO (0 / 0)

    I never heard my mother say anything stronger than "son of a gun!" growing up.  Then she married my stepdad, who introduced her to The Sopranos and Deadwood and she has learned how to correctly drop the f-bomb in appropriate situations.  Pretty funny.

    I've adopted all of her non-swear expressions in front of my son: lord love a duck, for the love of pete, son of a gun, shoot, and when I'm really upset, gosh darn it!

    Then again, we don't have HBO yet!

  • Social Change (0 / 0)

    I believe that swearing and what used to be called "obscene language" has gone through a period of social change in recent years.

    For most of my life (I'll be 67 this month) this kind of language was used only by men with other men. It was totally unacceptable around women and children. "Nice women" did not use this kind of language at all, ever, unless it was in the bedroom.

    My two eldest, now in their early 40's, do not swear in everyday speech. My younger two, in their 30's, do swear and use "colorful" speech but have NEVER DONE SO in front of their mom (me).

    My "baby" daughter, now 19, however, has been using the "F" word in casual conversation since she was in junior high and has refused to watch her language at home. Her father, who has always used this kind of language because it is "manly" has been horrified, shocked, and disappointed that his "little girl" would talk this way. As I said above, in our day "nice women" didn't use that kind of language.

    So swearing, in my opinion, is going through the same social process that short skirts on women went through in the 1920's, and long hair on men went through in the 1960's. These were major changes in social custom and caused huge inter-generational stress in families at the time.

    While swearing is becoming more socially acceptable in everyday society, it still hasn't reached "the tipping point", and this debate here reflects that.

    My advice to young parents, if you all don't mind being lectured by a senior citizen and grandma of five as well as a mom of five, is to ask yourself if you care if your kids use those words.

    If you don't care, then it's not a problem. If you do care, watch your speech. The old "do as I say, not as I do" doesn't work. You as parents are the role models for your kids. You will have more influence on them than anyone else, for better or for worse.

    If you don't care most of the time but would be embarassed if Junior swore in front of grandma, at pre-school, or at the store, etc; then you probably are still conflicted about it and need to sort out your attitudes.

    You really can't have it both ways. Perhaps when the kids are older, you can explain that it's okay in certain situations but not in others, etc. But this won't work with small children.

    • Instructions to my husband (0 / 0)

      I've said a dozen times:  "Don't say that in front of our son unless you want him repeating it to your mother!"  --because you KNOW that's what'll happen.  And we'd just as soon avoid being lectured by that particular senior citizen!
      • Too true! (0 / 0)

        My stepfather-in-law's mom told a story that when her husband came back from World War II, he was dropping the f-word pretty frequently.  It didn't particularly bother her (in fact, she has the honor of being the oldest person I've ever heard say that word).  One day, her mother-in-law came over for coffee, and her five-year-old son was playing on the floor.  He toppled his blocks or something, and let out an stream of expletives that was a glory to behold.  Her MIL clutched her heart in agony and she was horrified.  She gave her husband what-for when he got home from work, and they spent the next months trying to cleanse the words from their son's mind.

        Still, she was the kind of woman who, when her husband would refuse to use his hearing aid & then spend the day saying "What?", would go over to the drawer where the hearing aid was, open it, and say directly into the drawer, "Can you hear me now, asshole?"

Permalink | 99 comments